‘Five Dead, Two Injured’ in Hanwha Aerospace Explosion
Previous Explosions in 2018 and 2019
"If Safety Guidelines Were Perfectly Established but
the Accident Was Caused by a Worker’s Momentary Mistake,
Management Could Avoid Liability Under th

'Systemic Weakness' or 'Individual Negligence'... Management's Fate Under the Serious Accidents Punishment Act Hinges on the Cause View original image

The legal community is closely watching where the investigation into the explosion accident at Hanwha Aerospace's Daejeon plant will ultimately focus. Legal experts agree that, considering precedents of the Serious Accidents Punishment Act (SAPA), cases prosecuted under the Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA), and the defense mechanisms of large corporations, a protracted legal battle is expected before any punishment could be imposed on the CEO or other top management.


If an industrial accident results in the death of at least one person, or if at least two people are injured and require treatment for more than six months due to the same incident, it is classified as a serious industrial accident. The Serious Accidents Punishment Act is a law that allows for the criminal punishment of business owners by evaluating their safety and health obligations when a serious accident occurs. It is crucial to determine whether the employer took appropriate preventive measures against the accident.


The Yonhap News Agency

The Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Will Management Be Held Accountable?


According to the legal community on June 2, in response to this accident—which resulted in five deaths and two injuries—the Daejeon District Prosecutors' Office has formed a dedicated team (headed by Criminal Division 4 Chief Prosecutor Jeon Youngwoo, with three prosecutors and six investigators). The investigative authorities are expected to proceed with the case, taking into account public sentiment and the possibility that the victims’ families may file complaints.


Suh Sangwook, an attorney at Law Firm Imok, stated, "The targets of SAPA are those who ultimately oversee business operations and are at the apex of all internal decision-making processes, such as management responsible officers." However, Attorney A, an expert in serious accident cases at a major law firm, explained, "In practice, investigators look at three criteria: the CEO registered on the corporate registry, the person with final approval authority for safety and health matters according to the internal delegation regulations, and the actual final approver in internal documents. Large corporations tend to consolidate these roles under the registered CEO on the corporate registry to create a defense barrier, making it difficult for investigations to reach higher levels of management."


Whether the factory is a separate legal entity could also be a variable. Lee Kiyoon, an attorney at Law Firm Hyunjae, noted, "If the factory has been spun off as a separate legal entity and there was no real involvement from the head office, then the head office would not be considered the responsible management in either a formal or substantive sense." Previously, prosecutors indicted Do-Won Jung, Chairman of Sampyo Group, in connection with a quarry collapse, arguing that he exercised substantial authority, but the Uijeongbu District Court acquitted him. The rationale was that even if there were circumstances of document approval, if the person was not the registered CEO and there was a separate safety and health officer, it is difficult to view them as the party responsible for the obligations.


'Systemic Weakness' or 'Individual Negligence'... Management's Fate Under the Serious Accidents Punishment Act Hinges on the Cause View original image

Third Explosion Accident... The Key Issue: Systemic Deficiency


Whether the management, including the registered CEO, violated the SAPA depends on whether the accident was due to systemic deficiencies or individual negligence. Park Jisoon, a professor at Korea University Law School, commented, "If the company had perfect safety guidelines and risk assessment systems in place, but the accident resulted from a momentary mistake by a worker or engineer, then at most, the management could be found to have neglected on-site management or supervision (a violation of the OSHA), and could avoid a SAPA conviction." However, Professor Park added, "If the risk assessment was conducted only superficially and failed to identify fatal risks in the explosives cleaning process, then this would constitute a breach of the management's duties."


Notably, Hanwha Aerospace experienced two previous explosion accidents in 2018 and 2019. The existence of prior industrial accident cases involving violations of the OSHA can, at the discretion of the court, be considered as an aggravating factor during sentencing.



If the management is recognized as having fulfilled their SAPA obligations by establishing a dedicated safety and health organization and making appropriate investments, the ruling may resemble that of the "Yeochun NCC explosion accident," where eight casualties occurred but the company was acquitted under SAPA. In the first trial of the S-Oil Ulsan plant explosion, which resulted in ten casualties, the court classified the omission of basic on-site safety measures as "social negligence" and convicted only seven on-site staff members. Similarly, unless a concrete link can be established between the management's production pressures and the breakdown of on-site safety systems in the Hanwha Aerospace case, the outcome may be limited to punishing only the working-level staff, as seen in the S-Oil case.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing