"Undermining the Principle of Private Autonomy and Contractual Binding Force"

The Korean Bar Association announced on June 1 that it regrets recent court rulings in which some courts have retroactively reduced the attorney fees agreed upon in legally concluded contracts between lawyers and clients.

Korean Bar Association

Korean Bar Association

View original image

The Association stated that such judgments undermine the principle of private autonomy, which requires respecting contracts freely entered into by the parties, as well as the binding force of contracts. In particular, it criticized the courts for applying a double standard by intervening in attorney fee agreements based on abstract notions of equity, while, in the past, even recognizing the validity of donation documents executed under duress during the military regime. The Association argued that only attorney fee agreements are being subjected to this intervention, which is inconsistent with principles of fairness.


The Association insisted that the principle of private autonomy should apply equally to attorney fee agreements, except in rare cases such as violations of mandatory laws or public order. It emphasized that attorney fees are determined through a comprehensive assessment of the complexity of the case, the lawyer's expertise, and the anticipated responsibilities and risks, making mechanical evaluation impossible. The Association also highlighted that, even in a Supreme Court en banc decision, concerns were raised that the legal basis for reducing attorney fees is inconsistent with fairness compared to other professions.


The Association also raised concerns about the ambiguity of the court's standards for fee reduction. It argued that if the validity of contracts depends on the post hoc assessment of individual courts without objective grounds, legal stability would be seriously undermined and judicial predictability would decline. In a landscape where the development of online media and the increasing number of lawyers have improved clients' access to information and expanded their options, the Association assessed that treating clients as unilaterally disadvantaged parties and intervening in contracts is an excessively paternalistic approach detached from reality.



The Association further pointed out that, if this court practice continues, lawyers may avoid taking on complex and high-risk cases in order to evade unpredictable risks.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing