[The Police File]One Year of 'Acting Public Safety': Unable or Unwilling to Appoint a Police Chief? View original image

As nearly a year has passed since President Lee Jaemyung took office, the position of South Korea’s top law enforcement chief remains vacant. The absence of a police chief and the ongoing system of an acting commissioner have long become the norm. If the administration has been unable to appoint a police chief after nearly a year, it is either a matter of competence or of will. If it is neither, at the very least, there must be circumstances that need to be explained to the public.


Some within the administration may cite careful selection or thorough vetting as excuses. However, one year is more than enough time to find the head of the police organization. Even cooperation with the opposition or parliamentary confirmation hearings are not sufficient justifications, as the risks posed by a vacancy at the top of law enforcement are simply too great. Ultimately, it is difficult to avoid the conviction that the administration is not unable to make the appointment, but rather is deliberately choosing not to do so.


In a normal situation, it would be common sense to minimize the vacancy of the 'law enforcement control tower.' When the commissioner is unable to serve, a replacement should be found immediately, and a new leader appointed through a confirmation hearing, so that the organization can maintain direction and policy consistency. However, the current administration has left the police under an acting leadership system for nearly a year. Under such a temporary arrangement, which is no more than an interim management, the organization avoids bold reforms and shies away from taking risks. The longer this situation continues, the more the police will shrink into a bureaucracy preoccupied with reading the mood of the administration.


The problem is that this prolonged vacancy coincides with a period that can hardly be seen as a coincidence. At the height of local elections, the police are dealing with highly politically sensitive issues such as cracking down on election law violations and responding to fake news. The direction and speed of police investigations during elections can be powerful variables that shake the entire electoral landscape. Even though President Lee had ample time to make a decision if vetting began immediately after taking office, it is questionable why the appointment has been delayed until just before the local elections.


Leaders serving in an acting capacity without guaranteed formal terms of office tend to be overly cautious of the person with appointment authority, making it difficult to initiate investigations into sensitive suspicions related to the administration or elections that could touch on the administration’s Achilles’ heel. The current vacancy could be seen as a means of tying the hands of the police during the election period to create an environment favorable to the administration, with the intention of rewarding key appointments after the election results—a suspicion that is hard to dispel.


If the plan is to overhaul police appointments all at once after seeing the results of the local elections and aligning with the new power structure, that itself is a distorted view. The police commissioner is not a prize to be exchanged based on the outcome of an election. On the contrary, the position should be filled right after a change of administration, at a certain distance from the elections, based on neutrality and expertise. The idea of choosing a leader to suit the administration’s tastes after confirming the election results is no different from treating the police as mere pawns in a political game, rather than as a law enforcement agency.


The unique atmosphere of waiting and watching that comes with election season, combined with the long-term acting leadership, sends a fatal signal within the organization. Factionalism and bureaucratic caution take precedence over addressing pressing issues. When the appointing authority leaves the position of law enforcement chief vacant for so long, it effectively tells the entire organization to lie low for the time being. In the meantime, the vacuum and damage in law enforcement are borne by the front-line police officers fighting crime, and by the citizens who deserve police services.



This abnormal state of a 'proxy law enforcement state' must not be allowed to continue any longer. If the president intends to exercise responsible authority, the principles for appointing a police chief must be clarified, regardless of the election schedule. Making personnel decisions subordinate to the election calendar only undermines the independence of the police. Even now, the administration must move forward with the appointment of a new police chief.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing