“Special Recommendation on Labor Unions’ Demands for Profit Sharing” Distributed

The business community has recommended that, in response to the recent surge in labor unions’ demands for “N% performance bonuses,” it should be made clear from the outset that requests for institutionalizing profit sharing or specifying profit distribution ratios cannot be regarded as subjects for collective bargaining.


Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

On May 31, the Korea Employers Federation distributed a “Special Recommendation from Management on Labor Unions’ Demands for Corporate Profit Sharing” to its member companies.


The Federation pointed out, “Recently, labor unions at some major corporations have been demanding to formalize, through collective agreements, a system that allocates a certain percentage of operating profits to union members.” It added, “This type of demand is fundamentally different from existing performance-based pay systems, as it calls for the direct distribution of corporate profits to employees.”


The Federation also stated, “Corporate profits are management resources that should be used for investment, employment, research and development, and financial structure improvement in order to ensure a company’s sustainability and future competitiveness. When unions demand the preemptive distribution of profits, it raises concerns about potentially restricting shareholders’ rights.” The statement further noted, “It is difficult to find global companies overseas that have pre-arranged systems for allocating a fixed percentage of profits to employees.”


The Korea Employers Federation explained that the special recommendation was prepared because, “Although a company may use a portion of its profits for employees, the method of utilization should be determined and managed by the company’s own management decision, not through negotiation with labor unions.”


The recommendation asserts, “It should be clearly stated that monetary amounts distributed based on management performance, such as operating profit, do not constitute wages.” The Federation added, “The Supreme Court has consistently ruled that profit-sharing payments—whose provision or amount may vary according to business performance—are not considered wages, since they are not closely related to the provision of labor and are influenced more significantly by factors beyond employees’ control.”


The Federation further advised, “If unions insist in labor-management negotiations that the distribution of operating profits is a type of wage that must be paid, companies should clearly point out that such demands do not comply with the law or established judicial precedents.”


The Federation also emphasized, “Institutionalizing standards for the distribution of corporate profits falls within the realm of unique managerial decisions and cannot be made a subject of collective bargaining.” It explained, “Under the Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act, mandatory subjects for collective bargaining are limited to working conditions such as wages, working hours, welfare, dismissal, status, and other treatment of employees. Generally, profit sharing by a company does not constitute wages and is also difficult to classify as welfare or other treatment.”


KEF: "Performance Bonus Demands Not Subject to Collective Bargaining... Not Included as Wages" View original image

The Federation stressed that “companies have no legal obligation to comply with labor union demands for profit sharing, and in general, strikes or other industrial actions carried out by unions with profit sharing as their main objective may be deemed illegal in terms of their purpose.”



The Federation emphasized that performance-based pay systems should be operated rationally, grounded in the principles of sustainability and meritocracy. The Federation added, “Performance-based pay should not be regarded as a simple profit distribution, but rather as a means of incentivizing employees to improve productivity and generate company results.” It further stated, “It is preferable to operate performance-based pay systems in a way that aligns the interests of both the company and its employees over the medium to long term, such as through conditional stock compensation, rather than focusing on short-term cash rewards.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing