Campaign Pledge Report Card Serves as a Compass for Undecided Voters

"Addressing Identified Weaknesses, Final All-Out Push"

How do civic groups view the campaign pledges of Busan mayoral candidates?


With the local elections approaching, the assessment results of Busan mayoral candidates’ pledges, released by civil society organizations, have emerged as a potential variable that could sway undecided voters at the last minute. Each candidate received a “mixed report card” that clearly highlighted their respective strengths and weaknesses.


Jeon Jae-soo, the candidate from the Democratic Party of Korea, was recognized for “relevance”; Park Hyung-joon, the candidate from the People Power Party, for “concreteness”; and Jung Ihan, the candidate from the Reform New Party, for “clarity” in message. However, it was also analyzed that all three candidates share the common challenge of “reliance on external funding.”


On May 27, one week before the election, the Busan Citizens’ Coalition for Economic Justice announced its evaluation of the three Busan mayoral candidates’ core pledges at a briefing room in the Busan Metropolitan Council. A panel of experts, including university professors, comprehensively assessed each candidate’s three main pledges based on criteria such as concreteness, relevance, reform-mindedness, and competence. While the three candidates demonstrated strengths in different areas, the panel also pointed out areas that need improvement for each.


Candidate Jeon was rated highly in the “issue relevance” category for accurately identifying structural problems facing Busan, such as population aging and youth outflow. Proposals for progressive policies like “youth basic income” and “universal care allowance” were also positively evaluated. However, his large-scale infrastructure pledges, including the early opening of the Gadeokdo New Airport and undergrounding the Gyeongbu Line, were criticized for their low feasibility within the term and high dependence on central government finances and authority, indicating a lack of independent momentum.


Candidate Park received the highest marks in the “fiscal concreteness” category of his pledges. The self-revolving fund design and data-driven fiscal simulation presented in his “Busan Chance” policy for youth asset building were recognized as efforts to demonstrate policy implementability. However, concerns were raised about the sustainability of the 50 billion won in funding from Busan Urban Corporation’s dividend recovery, vulnerability to external variables such as reliance on national government project funding, and a relative lack of reform-mindedness.


Candidate Jung stood out for the clarity and originality of his messaging, distinguishing himself between the two major party candidates. He proposed pledges that citizens can easily relate to, such as a “Sa-jik retractable dome stadium” and attracting a “Netflix House,” which were evaluated as meaningful for city branding. On the other hand, the lack of concrete fiscal plans led to concerns about feasibility. The evaluation panel noted that while the pledge emphasized a “private investment-centered” approach, it fell short of providing specific funding procurement measures.


The panel identified “uncertainty in securing funding” and “limitations of local finances” as common challenges across all three candidates’ pledges. While visions and policy ideas were presented, there was a relative lack of independent fiscal solutions to support them.


The panel commented, “All three candidates are somewhat lacking in providing solutions for how to secure substantial funding,” adding, “since many pledges are predicated on cooperation from the central government, there are limits to autonomous execution.”



With only three days left before the election, these assessment results are likely to serve as a compass for undecided voters who have yet to choose a candidate. Each campaign is now focused on addressing their weaknesses and maximizing their strengths in a final push for votes.

Ahead of the 9th nationwide local elections, on the 24th, voting information and election newsletters were delivered to the mailboxes of an apartment complex in Suyeong District, Busan. [Image source=Yonhap News]

Ahead of the 9th nationwide local elections, on the 24th, voting information and election newsletters were delivered to the mailboxes of an apartment complex in Suyeong District, Busan. [Image source=Yonhap News]

View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing