FSS Nears Completion of Review... Separate Sanctions Committee Unlikely
Final Decision Expected at FSC Meeting on June 17

The final decision on penalties for incomplete sales of equity-linked securities (ELS) tied to the Hang Seng China Enterprises Index (HSCEI) has ultimately been postponed until after the June 3 local elections. There is speculation that financial authorities have delayed the decision to reduce political pressure, such as controversy over consumer protection, especially as they are expected to significantly reduce the fines.


Hong Kong ELS Fine Decision Postponed Until After June 3... Was a Major Reduction a Burden? View original image

According to financial authorities on May 29, the Financial Supervisory Service is currently in the final stage of reviewing the penalty proposal for HSCEI ELS, and the proposal is expected to be submitted to the regular meeting of the Financial Services Commission scheduled for June 17.


A financial authority official stated, "The Financial Supervisory Service is finalizing the supplementation of facts and applicable legal principles," and added, "It is likely that the proposal will be tabled at the next regular meeting of the Financial Services Commission."


Previously, on May 13, the Financial Services Commission took the unusual step of returning the Financial Supervisory Service’s penalty proposal on HSCEI ELS for further review. The Financial Supervisory Service had originally imposed a total of 1.4 trillion won in fines on five banks—KB Kookmin, Shinhan, Hana, NH Nonghyup, and Standard Chartered Bank Korea—in February, but the Financial Services Commission requested supplementation of certain facts and legal grounds. In particular, it was noted that similar sentencing standards were applied to different issues, such as banks’ risk rating classification and application problems, and cases of securities firms violating their duty to explain products. As such, a review of these points was deemed necessary.


The final amount of fines will be adjusted based on the results of the Financial Supervisory Service’s supplementation of facts and legal principles. The Financial Services Commission initially considered the 1.4 trillion won fine excessive, and Lee Chanjin, Governor of the Financial Supervisory Service, shared this view. Both agencies agree that a reduction is necessary to encourage banks’ voluntary compensation efforts and to allow for sufficient capital to promote productive finance. The Financial Supervisory Service explained that it did not have the authority to make discretionary reductions, making it difficult to lower the initial fines further.


For now, the Financial Supervisory Service is inclined not to convene a separate sanctions review committee again. Since no new issues have arisen, it believes that further discussion at the committee level is unnecessary. It is also aware that reconvening the committee itself could be interpreted as overturning the previous decision, which would be a burden. Once working-level discussions between the Financial Services Commission and the Financial Supervisory Service are concluded, the final amount of fines is expected to be decided at the regular meeting of the Financial Services Commission.


A financial authority official commented, "At this stage, the Financial Supervisory Service does not have significant discretion to adjust the fines," and added, "Since the scope for reductions by the Financial Supervisory Service is limited by regulations, the final amount will be determined at the regular meeting of the Financial Services Commission."


Within and outside the banking sector, there are expectations that the final fines could be reduced to around 500 billion to 600 billion won. Governor Lee Chanjin also told reporters earlier that the ELS fine "will naturally fall below 1 trillion won" and "it will not be in the trillion-won range."



A financial industry insider remarked, "The Financial Services Commission has held nearly 15 subcommittee meetings to discuss the imposition of ELS fines, and its request for a further review from the Financial Supervisory Service was essentially aimed at laying the groundwork for a reduction. It appears that the financial authorities intend to determine the extent of the final reduction after comprehensively considering public sentiment and other factors following the local elections."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing