Restoring the Constitutional Advisory Body Chaired by the President

“Preventing Recurrence Through Systems, Not Individuals”

Livestreaming Advisory Council Meetings and Strengthening Committee Coordination

Focusing on AI, Energy, and Public Data Initiatives

Lee Kyungsoo, Vice Chairman of the National Science and Technology Advisory Council, has openly acknowledged criticism that the council has become a mere "rubber stamp" in light of the controversy sparked by the national research and development (R&D) budget cuts. He declared his intention to restore public trust and normalize the council's operations. He admitted that this constitutional advisory body, chaired by the president, failed to fulfill its intended role in accordance with laws and procedures, and emphasized that, moving forward, the system will prevent similar issues from recurring without relying on the will of any specific individual.

Lee Kyungsoo, Vice Chairman of the National Science and Technology Advisory Council, is answering questions from reporters. Photo by Kim Joungho

Lee Kyungsoo, Vice Chairman of the National Science and Technology Advisory Council, is answering questions from reporters. Photo by Kim Joungho

View original image

At a press briefing held in the main conference room of the National Science and Technology Advisory Council in Gwanghwamun, Seoul, on May 28, Vice Chairman Lee stated, "When reporting to the president, I made it clear that the council has faced criticism for acting as a 'rubber stamp,'" adding, "The most important thing now is to regain trust."


The National Science and Technology Advisory Council is a presidential advisory body on science and technology, established under Article 127 of the Constitution. With the president serving as chair, the council advises on strategies for national scientific and technological advancement and key policy directions. It also deliberates on major science and technology policies, such as the allocation and coordination of the national R&D budget.


The main issue Vice Chairman Lee pointed out was whether the council had sufficiently fulfilled its role as both a presidential advisory body and the highest policy deliberation entity during the substantial R&D budget reductions in 2023.


He commented, "There was a significant reduction in the science and technology R&D budget, and there were also incidents—epitomized by the so-called 'silenced voices'—that hurt the pride of the scientific community. The entire nation witnessed these events."


He went on to explain, "The biggest cause was forgetting or ignoring the fact that this council is chaired by the president. Although it is the highest advisory body directly under the president, it failed to exercise effective checks and adjustments during the R&D budget cut process."


"Uncertain Whether Advice Was Even Read"…Expanding Disclosure on YouTube


Vice Chairman Lee also announced plans to change the council's operating methods. He said the council will livestream its discussions online whenever possible and release meeting content, allowing both the public and the science and technology community to observe the advisory process.


He said, "I have often been asked whether the reports prepared by the council were properly delivered to the president and whether they were actually read. Going forward, we will ensure that the public can see what topics the council discusses and how these are turned into advisory proposals."


However, he also noted that sensitive issues related to national strategy or security would still require closed-door discussions.


Additionally, he explained that the council will expand cross-participation and regular communication between the advisory and deliberative committees, creating a feedback loop whereby advisory results inform the deliberation process and policy issues identified during deliberations are brought back as new advisory topics.


AI Talent, Energy, Public Data…Four Key Initiatives


This year, the National Science and Technology Advisory Council will focus on four core agenda items centered on the major shift to artificial intelligence (AI): nurturing science and technology talent for the AI era; reorganizing national key technology systems around AI; strengthening energy competitiveness as AI data centers proliferate; and establishing an integrated management system to turn public R&D data into a national asset.


In particular, Vice Chairman Lee emphasized the strategic use of public data. He stated, "It is fair to assume that most data openly available on the internet has already been used by global big tech companies for training. What matters now is the data held by public institutions."


He further explained, "We need to establish how to utilize not only R&D outputs but also data from each ministry and public agency—including health, energy, and administration—for national innovation."



The restructuring of government-funded research institutes and the project-based system (PBS) was also identified as a major task. Vice Chairman Lee stressed, "There is a strong demand to redesign the entire system so that researchers can focus on research and innovation. It is essential to establish a framework where the entire R&D cycle operates seamlessly—from policy formulation and budget allocation to performance evaluation and feedback."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing