"Used Car Seller Must Return Unjust Enrichment to Buyer Even If Payment Was Sent to Fraudster"
The Supreme Court has ruled that, even if a used car seller remits the payment received from the buyer to a fraudster, the seller must return the funds to the buyer if the sales contract was not established.
The Civil Division 1 of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Cheon Daeyeop) overturned the previous ruling on April 16 and remanded the case filed by seller A against buyer B for the delivery of a vehicle to the Daegu District Court (2025Da219380).
A view of a used car sales complex in Gangseo-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency
View original image[Facts]
Seller A listed a used car for sale at 47 million won in November 2023. An unidentified fraudster intervened, impersonating the buyer to A and impersonating the seller to buyer B. Buyer B agreed to purchase the car for 38.5 million won.
At the fraudster's request, seller A pretended to be a car delivery driver and handed over the vehicle and the relevant documents to buyer B. Buyer B transferred 38.5 million won to A's account. Fooled by the fraudster, who said, "Send back the 38.5 million won due to tax reasons, and I will send you 47 million won," A then transferred 38.5 million won to the fraudster. A never received the 47 million won.
Seller A requested that buyer B return the vehicle, but was refused. A filed a lawsuit, claiming, "The sales contract was never established, and the money received was sent to the fraudster, so I did not unjustly benefit."
[Key Issue]
The key issue was whether, in the absence of mutual agreement on the payment amount between seller and buyer and thus no valid contract, the seller is still obligated to return unjust enrichment to the buyer, even if the payment was sent to the fraudster. If such an obligation is recognized, the seller's duty to return unjust enrichment would be fulfilled concurrently with the buyer's duty to return the vehicle.
[Lower Court Rulings]
The court of first instance ruled, "Buyer B must deliver the vehicle to seller A upon receiving 38.5 million won from A." The court recognized that A was obliged to return the 38.5 million won as unjust enrichment. It also stated that the duty to deliver the vehicle and the duty to return the payment must be performed concurrently.
However, the appeals court reversed the first ruling and ordered, "Buyer B must deliver the vehicle to seller A." The appeals court held that the 38.5 million won did not actually accrue to A, and thus A was not obligated to return unjust enrichment.
[Supreme Court Decision]
The Supreme Court overturned and remanded the appeals court decision, providing the following rationale:
- The act of seller A delivering the car and buyer B making the payment are inseparable parts of a single transaction. Since the car was effectively transferred to B, there is no reason to treat the payment made to A differently.
- There was no mutual agreement on the sales price between seller A and buyer B. Even if it is difficult to conclude that a sales contract was established, both parties still have an obligation to restore the original state by returning unjust enrichment.
- Since seller A delivered the car, if A returns the sales payment at the fraudster's request, A faces the risk of losing both the car and the sales payment. Such a return is highly unusual and abnormal in ordinary business practices. If A knew or should have known of this risk and still returned the money, this is considered a separate act of disposition occurring after the payment belonged to A.
- Seller A, aiming for a higher payment, created a false appearance by pretending to be a delivery driver. Buyer B took standard measures to verify the transaction. Imposing the obligation to return unjust enrichment on A aligns with the principles of fairness and justice.
- The lower court misunderstood the legal principles regarding the formation of unjust enrichment and the actual accrual of benefit.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Lee Sangwoo, Legal Times Reporter
※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.