“Third Grade or Fifth Grade?”

SCIA-Bound Prosecutors Face a “Rank Structure” Dilemma

Special Posts Without Official Grades to Be Incorporated into General Service

Balancing Recruitment Incentives and Fairness at Issue

With the launch of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (SCIA) approaching, the Prosecution Reform Task Force under the Office of the Prime Minister and the SCIA Establishment Preparation Committee, which are responsible for designing the organization, have found themselves in a "rank determination dilemma." This is because the calculation for what grade to assign to prosecutors joining the SCIA is complicated. As prosecutors, who were previously in special posts without an official rank, are now being incorporated into the general government employee system, the agencies must simultaneously consider both recruitment incentives and fairness with other ministries.


According to relevant ministries on May 27, those who pass the civil service examination are appointed as Fifth Grade (Assistant Director), and then promoted to Fourth Grade (Director) and Third Grade (Deputy Director-General). Above the Senior Civil Service positions for Bureau Directors (Second Grade equivalent) and Executive Directors (First Grade equivalent) are the political appointee posts of Vice Minister and Minister. In contrast, prosecutors are classified as "special posts" alongside judges under the public official pay regulations. They have not had official numerical grades, but their treatment has varied depending on seniority and position within the organization.

What Grade Should Be Assigned to Prosecutors Joining the SCIA? View original image

Traditionally, when a new prosecutor was appointed, it was customary for them to receive treatment equivalent to a Third Grade Director in central government ministries. There was no official rank, but in terms of salary, they were at the Third Grade level from the moment they were appointed. However, it is difficult to apply this directly to the general government employee system. In ordinary ministries, it takes 15 to 20 years to rise from Fifth Grade to Third Grade. Assigning an early-career SCIA prosecutor as Third or Fourth Grade right away could raise fairness issues with other ministries. It is also worth considering that lawyers who have graduated from law school and join central government ministries typically start at the Sixth Grade level.


An official familiar with the SCIA situation said, "For example, if a deputy chief prosecutor joins, they may be given a Bureau Director (Second Grade) position but have their salary matched to the First Grade level. In other words, treatment should be tailored carefully, taking into account individual seniority, career history, recent positions held, and special prosecutor experience." Another official from a central ministry said, "Serious thought must be given to how the de facto 'rank inflation' that prosecutors have enjoyed will be handled after the SCIA is established," adding, "The issue of rank asymmetry between those who passed the civil service and bar exams also needs to be considered."



Some have floated the idea of separating rank and compensation. Article 4, Section 6 of the supplementary provisions of the SCIA Act stipulates that "if the salary of a person appointed is less than what they received prior to appointment, the previous salary amount shall be compensated." Since it is not legally possible to reduce the compensation of prosecutors joining the newly created agency, there is also the option of adjusting the step system within each grade, such as noting that the base salary for Step 30 of Fifth Grade on the 2026 public servant pay scale (about 5.61 million won per month) is roughly equivalent to the starting step of Third Grade.

What Grade Should Be Assigned to Prosecutors Joining the SCIA? View original image

The main issue, however, is fairness. Depending on their experience, there could be situations where existing investigators outrank prosecutors in terms of grade. Even if rank and compensation incentives are provided as a temporary "open event" to encourage initial prosecutors to join, there are concerns that their job security could become more unstable once this period ends. Above all, since the SCIA will be an external agency under the Ministry of the Interior and Safety and its chief will be at the Vice Minister level, the more high-ranking prosecutors are brought in, the narrower the internal rank structure becomes. A former prosecutor considering joining the SCIA said, "If my rank or salary is reduced, there is no real reason for me to make the move," adding, "I will decide whether to apply after reviewing the specific terms of employment in the recruitment notice."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing