Apology Is an Accumulation, Not an Event
Ideological Framing Should Not Extend to Consumer Choices

[Reporter’s Notebook] The True Measure of an Apology Lies in What Follows View original image


"I take full responsibility."


Chung Yongjin, Chairman of Shinsegae Group, bowed his head on the 26th. This public apology comes eight days after controversy erupted over Starbucks Korea's "Tank Day" event, which was criticized for allegedly disparaging the May 18 Gwangju Democratization Movement.


Starbucks first entered Korea in 1999, opening its inaugural store near Ewha Womans University. More than just a coffee brand, it functioned as a space where people consumed an 'image.' For some, Starbucks was a workspace; for others, it symbolized a particular mode of consumption. What Shinsegae has been selling all along was this image-driven sensibility. As a company that has long built its assets around a sophisticated lifestyle and premium branding, the blow from this controversy is more significant in terms of damage to brand trust than to sales.


For this reason, the Starbucks incident left a mark that goes beyond a marketing failure. Consumers' disappointment was not with the name "Tank Day" itself, but with the fact that the name was approved through four layers of decision-making without anyone recognizing a problem. In fact, at Chairman Chung's press conference, Shinsegae acknowledged that the review by the corporate social responsibility (CSR) and legal teams had been omitted, and that marketing approvals had been granted by habit, focusing only on sales. The group admitted at the organizational level that this was not simply an individual's deviation, but a 'system failure.'


In 2019, Musinsa, which faced similar criticism over historical awareness, saw its CEO Jo Manho visit the Park Jongcheol Memorial Foundation directly after a public apology. That meeting did not end as a one-off event but has continued for seven years. In other words, it was the actions taken over several years, rather than a single apology statement, that proved the sincerity of the apology.


The sincerity of an apology is proven through the accumulation of time. In this press conference, Shinsegae pledged measures to prevent recurrence, including historical awareness training and strengthening its internal verification system. What consumers who have closed their wallets to Starbucks will pay attention to is not the apology statement made at the press conference, but how Shinsegae changes over time. Apology is not a one-time event, but a process of accumulation.


However, criticizing a company for its wrongdoing and pushing consumer choices into the realm of ideological camps are two different matters. Some consumers may turn away, while others may continue to use Starbucks. If even those choices are interpreted in political terms, consumption ceases to be a matter of personal taste and freedom and instead becomes a tool for ideological scrutiny.



The sincerity of an apology cannot be achieved in a single-day press conference. The dignity of an apology lies in what comes after.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing