Original Verdict Overturned, Sentenced to 2 to 3 Years in Prison

A teenager who assaulted a neighbor in his 70s during an argument with his mother, resulting in the neighbor's death, has received a heavier prison sentence on appeal compared to the initial trial.


On May 26, the Gwangju High Court's 2nd Criminal Division (Presiding Judge Hwang Jinhee) overturned the original verdict and sentenced 17-year-old A to a prison term ranging from 2 to 3 years, after he had previously been sentenced to a prison term ranging from 1 to 2 years in the first trial for charges including injury resulting in death.

Exterior view of Gwangju High Court.

Exterior view of Gwangju High Court.

View original image

The appellate court accepted only the prosecutor's appeal, which claimed the original sentence was too lenient. For A's mother, who was also tried for assault, the court upheld the original fine of 1 million won and dismissed both the prosecutor's and the defendant's appeals.


A was indicted for punching and killing his 70-something neighbor, identified as C, near a house in Hyeongyeong-myeon, Muan-gun, South Jeolla Province, at around 5:40 p.m. on October 13, 2024. A's mother was tried together for shoving C's shoulder during the argument on the same day.


At the time, A was a middle school student and is reported to have committed the crime in a fit of anger after witnessing C arguing with his mother. C suffered a skull fracture and severe head injuries and was rushed to the hospital by emergency services, but ultimately died four days later.


This case, which became known locally as the "Muan Elderly Injury Resulting in Death Incident," drew public outrage as the bereaved family demanded severe punishment, claiming the perpetrator showed no remorse after fatally assaulting an elderly neighbor with whom they had a longstanding relationship.


The appellate court stated, "A has admitted to all the facts, and it is recognized that the crime was somewhat impulsive after witnessing the argument involving his mother."


However, the court pointed out, "Even though the altercation between the mother and the victim was subsiding, A suddenly ran up and struck the victim's face twice, which constitutes an active act of aggression. Furthermore, after witnessing the victim collapse and lose consciousness as a result of his assault, A took no action to help and left the victim unattended, making the circumstances after the crime very unfavorable."



The court explained its sentencing rationale by stating, "Given the defendant's responsibility and the consequences of the crime, the sentence handed down in the first trial was unjustifiably lenient."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing