Sanctions Imposed on 'You & iPhone' and 'Reold' Operators for Fraudulent Practices
After Surge in Delivery Complaints and Card Payment Block, Consumers Urged to Pay by Bank Transfer

Operators of used phone online marketplaces (cybermalls) that caused billions of won in damages by falsely advertising used iPhones at low prices online, collecting payments, and then delaying both delivery and refunds, have received a slew of sanctions. In particular, a representative who continued so-called 'defiant business practices' by ignoring a local government's order to restore its dispute resolution counseling center and disconnecting the contact number, has ultimately been reported to the prosecution.

Used iPhone Scam Marketplaces Busted... Fair Trade Commission Sanctions JB International and Others, Refers CEO to Prosecution View original image

The Fair Trade Commission announced on the 26th that it has decided to impose a prohibition order and public announcement order, suspend business operations for 4.5 months, and impose an administrative fine of 7 million won on JB International and All That, which operate the used iPhone cybermalls 'You & iPhone' and 'Reold', respectively. In addition, it reported that it has referred Mr. Ahn, the representative who failed to comply with the local government's corrective order, to the prosecution. Both cybermalls are operated under the same representative, Mr. Ahn.

"Delivery in 2 weeks" promise, then disappearance... When card payment was blocked, they switched to direct bank transfer

According to the Fair Trade Commission, JB International supplied used iPhones via overseas purchasing agencies through You & iPhone, advertising on social media and elsewhere that it would take 2 to 4 weeks for delivery. However, in reality, there were cases where products were not delivered for several months, or consumers who canceled their orders did not receive refunds.


After complaints about delivery delays surged, and credit card payments were blocked by the payment gateway provider in October last year, CEO Ahn encouraged consumers to pay by direct bank transfer, showing boldness in misappropriating consumer payments. When it became difficult to continue sales on You & iPhone, CEO Ahn registered a new business name, 'All That', and launched a new cybermall called 'Reold', continuing the same fraudulent sales tactics for used iPhones and engaging in a 'cybermall rotation' scheme.


Because they completely failed to fulfill their obligation to display the representative's name, email address, or a link to the Fair Trade Commission's business information disclosure page on the main page, they operated covertly, significantly increasing consumer damage. The confirmed amount of consumer damage from these practices alone amounted to approximately 600 million won (based on delivery records from June to mid-November last year), and the actual damage is estimated to be even greater when including unreported cases. The Fair Trade Commission had already blocked access to these cybermalls by issuing a provisional suspension order in December last year to prevent further damage.

Accepted local government order, then "blew up customer center"... Representative reported to prosecution

CEO Ahn is now facing criminal penalties for disregarding a corrective order from the local government, specifically the Ilsandong District Office of Goyang City. In October last year, after more than 50 complaints were filed regarding delayed refunds and unresponsive customer service, the district office recommended that the company operate a functioning telephone customer center, and CEO Ahn accepted this recommendation. Under the Electronic Commerce Act, accepting such a recommendation is considered the same as receiving a corrective order.


However, CEO Ahn only posted the customer center number on the shopping mall's main page, and then deliberately disconnected the phone consultation channel, leaving calls stuck on a perpetual busy signal. In January this year, it was discovered that the number had been completely disconnected and even the KakaoTalk channel had been closed. This constitutes a violation of Article 40, Clause 2 of the Electronic Commerce Act regarding non-compliance with corrective orders, and is punishable by imprisonment of up to three years or a fine of up to 100 million won.



The Fair Trade Commission stated, "By reporting a business operator who failed to comply with a corrective order, the investigations and measures taken by the Fair Trade Commission and local governments can be more effective," adding, "We will continue to monitor deceptive acts against consumers and violations of the Electronic Commerce Act, and work closely with local governments and related agencies to strictly enforce the law in future similar cases."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing