"Routine Approval of Marketing Proposals by Young Staff"... Starbucks Incident, a Failure of Risk Management
Shinsegae Unable to Find Evidence of Prior Collusion
Some Employees Refused to Submit Mobile Phones
Internal Control Lapses Found as Legal Review Was Skipped
Group Refutes Online Allegations as "Untrue"
Shinsegae Group has released the results of its internal investigation regarding the controversy over Starbucks Korea's 'Tank Day' event, which took place on the anniversary of the May 18 Gwangju Democratization Movement. The company announced, "We did not find any intentional attempt to disparage May 18." However, they admitted that the internal risk management system failed during the marketing approval process, leading to the dismissal or suspension of Son Jeonghyeon, CEO of Starbucks Korea, the executive in charge, and the relevant employees. Regarding online suspicions such as the "503ml capacity" and "21% discount rate," the group denied any intentional meaning, saying, "These numbers were not chosen with any particular intent."
On May 26, following Chairman Yongjin Chung's apology press conference at the Chosun Palace Hotel in Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Shinsegae Group announced the investigation results and follow-up measures. In attendance at the briefing were Kyu-Bong Lee, Executive Vice President of Management Support; Sangjin Jeon, Executive Vice President of Management; Suwan Kim, Head of External Cooperation; and Jonghwan Yang, Audit Team Leader.
Executive Vice President Sangjin Jeon stated, "If, during the subsequent investigation, any intent to disparage the May 18 Democratization Movement is found, the employees involved will be immediately disciplined and held civilly and criminally responsible."
Officials from Shinsegae Group are conducting a Q&A session after Chairman Yongshin Jung's public apology regarding the Starbucks Korea 'Tank Day' controversy at the Chosun Palace Hotel in Gangnam-gu, Seoul, on the 26th. From left: Kyu-Bong Lee, Executive Vice President of Management Support; Sangjin Jeon, Executive Vice President of Management; Suwan Kim, Head of External Cooperation Headquarters; Jonghwan Yang, Audit Team Leader. 2026.5.26 Photo by Jin-Hyung Kang
View original imageIntentional Planning? Could Not Confirm Advance Collusion
Shinsegae Group conducted an internal investigation for one week, starting on May 19, targeting Starbucks Korea executives and employees, immediately after the controversy over Starbucks' "5·18 Tank Day Event" arose. The core of the investigation was to determine whether the marketing was planned with a specific intention, and whether the internal approval and risk management processes were functioning properly.
Executive Director Jonghwan Yang stated, "We carried out forensic investigations on internal emails, work laptops, and internal messengers for a total of 15 people, including 5 executives, 5 staff members, and 5 in the approval line." He added, "We cross-checked digital evidence and interviews to confirm whether there was any advance collusion or supporting evidence." However, there were also limitations to the investigation. Some employees refused to submit their personal mobile phones, which was a key issue related to the "tank" naming controversy.
Executive Vice President Jeon said, "Out of the five employees involved in planning the event, two voluntarily submitted their mobile phones, saying they wanted to prove their lack of involvement, but the remaining three refused to do so, citing privacy concerns. Therefore, it was difficult to completely determine whether there had been any advance collusion." He continued, "Reviewing internal messenger conversations, we confirmed that the employees were quite taken aback after the controversy arose. Based on this, we believe it is less likely that there was premeditated collusion." However, he added, "Since we did not conduct forensic analysis of all personal mobile phones, we cannot say this definitively."
Vice President Suwan Kim stated, "After this incident, the company reviewed all major promotions and event schedules that Starbucks has conducted over the past 10 years. We looked for any evidence of deliberately scheduling repeated events on specific dates such as April 16 or May 18, but typically, Starbucks holds promotions on a biweekly basis and introduces new events every week, so it is possible for certain anniversaries or dates to overlap with promotions."
Approvals Given Without Reviewing Designs, Admitting Internal Control Failure
Shinsegae Group identified organizational culture and failures in internal controls as the core causes of this incident. The investigation found that the marketing plan passed through four stages of approval — from staff, team leader, executive in charge, head of strategic planning, to the CEO — but no one pointed out the inappropriateness of the '5·18 Tank Day' terminology.
Executive Vice President Jeon explained, "Among the seven individuals who approved the marketing event, some authorized it without even opening the attached design files, simply following past conventions. In prioritizing speed, the previously standard legal review was also skipped." He added, "Even if the event planner made a poor judgment, this could have been prevented if the internal control system had functioned properly. The company views this incident as a failure of risk management."
The issue of organizational culture was also raised. Vice President Suwan Kim commented, "The employees responsible for this marketing were composed of two in their early 20s and three in their early 30s. There appears to have been a gap between their historical or social awareness and the standards expected by the company and society." He continued, "During the internal investigation, there were numerous remarks indicating that the employees did not fully grasp the gravity or social impact of the issue. The company is taking this matter very seriously."
Kim further stated, "This should not be viewed simply as a matter of staff error. It is an issue of whether the entire organization shares a proper understanding of history and social sensitivity. The group will introduce educational programs on historical awareness that encompass not only employees in their 20s and 30s, but also those in their 40s, 50s, and 60s."
"Both 503ml and 21% Discount Were Coincidental"... Denying Online Suspicions
Shinsegae Group refuted the various suspicions that have spread online. First, regarding the claim that the "Tank Tumbler" name was intended to evoke the tanks used by martial law troops during the May 18 incident, the group emphasized, "This is not true."
The group explained that the product was manufactured by an overseas company and that the name "Tank" is the manufacturer's official product name, inspired by the shape of an actual water tank. They also addressed the claim that the "503ml capacity" was a reference to the prisoner number of a specific individual, stating, "The number comes from converting the original 17-ounce capacity to milliliters."
According to the group, the same product has been sold in Korea as well as in Australia, Thailand, and other countries since 2023 with the same capacity, and in some countries such as Japan and Slovakia, the 17-ounce capacity is also labeled as 503ml.
Regarding the release date of the Mini Tank Tumbler, which was set for April 16, the group stated, "It was not intended to target the anniversary of the Sewol ferry disaster." Starbucks Korea initially proposed an April 20 release, but during scheduling with the external event agency, April 16 was confirmed.
On the suspicion that the "21% discount on the Tank Duo Set" was meant to symbolize May 21, 1980, the day of the mass shooting during the Gwangju Democratization Movement, the group explained, "The discount rate was the result of price adjustments during the promotion process and had no connection to a specific date." Executive Vice President Jeon elaborated, "The original price of the Mini Tank Tumbler was 25,000 won, and it was reduced to 12,500 won during the promotion. The set price was changed from 60,000 won to 47,500 won. The discount rate resulted from the product composition and price adjustments, not from any intention to reference a specific date."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Regarding some criticism that the company is simply "cutting off the tail," the group stated, "We will pursue further accountability based on the investigation results," and drew a firm line by saying, "Chairman Yongjin Chung's past statements are unrelated to this Starbucks marketing controversy."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.