"Chairman Yongjin Chung: 'I Take Full Responsibility'"

Chairman Chung Considering Apology Visit to Gwangju

"All Processes Shared with U.S. Headquarters... 'Call Option Not Mentioned'"

On the 26th, Shinsegae Group clarified its position regarding whether Starbucks’ U.S. headquarters would exercise its call option in relation to the controversy over the 5·18 Tank Day event held by Starbucks Korea, stating, “The (U.S. Starbucks) headquarters has not raised this issue.”


Jangjin Jeon, Executive Vice President of Shinsegae Group, announced the results of the investigation into the event immediately after Chairman Yongjin Chung’s public apology at the Chosun Palace Hotel in Gangnam-gu, Seoul. He said, “Although the contract (with Starbucks U.S. headquarters) contains a call option clause, we do not believe this incident falls under its scope.”


Currently, Emart is the largest shareholder of Starbucks Korea, holding a 67.5% stake. In July 2021, Emart acquired an additional 17.5% stake in Starbucks Korea from Starbucks Coffee International, a U.S. Starbucks corporate entity, at which time the U.S. headquarters included a call option clause. The call option allows the seller to buy back the shares; if the agreement is terminated due to reasons attributable to Emart, the Starbucks headquarters can acquire all of Emart’s shares at a 35% discount to the fair market value.


As a result, concerns were raised that Starbucks U.S. headquarters might exercise the call option due to the Tank Day controversy, fearing a deterioration of the brand image.



Jung Yongjin, Chairman of Shinsegae Group, is issuing a public apology regarding the controversy of Starbucks Korea's "Tank Day" at the Chosun Palace Hotel in Gangnam-gu, Seoul on the 26th. May 26, 2026. Photo by Kang Jinhyung

Jung Yongjin, Chairman of Shinsegae Group, is issuing a public apology regarding the controversy of Starbucks Korea's "Tank Day" at the Chosun Palace Hotel in Gangnam-gu, Seoul on the 26th. May 26, 2026. Photo by Kang Jinhyung

View original image

The following is a Q&A with Jangjin Jeon, Executive Vice President of Shinsegae Group.


Q. About a week has passed since the incident occurred and the investigation results were announced. What specific actions have been taken over the past week?

A. Forensics were conducted on internal emails and work laptops of a total of 15 employees, including 5 executives, 5 employees handling practical tasks, and 5 people involved in the approval process. In addition, we investigated work tools such as internal messengers to check whether any prior collusion took place and whether there was any digital evidence to support it. Cross-verification interviews were also conducted.


Q. This incident sparked widespread outrage nationwide, and especially, citizens of Gwangju and bereaved families and organizations related to the 5·18 incident were deeply hurt. Does Chairman Yongjin Chung plan to visit them in person to apologize?

A. We are considering a visit at an appropriate time in the future. However, I believe that clarifying the facts should take priority. Many people are curious as to why the investigation took so long. Internally, the company has its own procedures, and following those procedures led to some delays. There are also aspects that remain unresolved. Therefore, the first priority is to clarify the facts, and when the time is right, we will publicly express our intentions, including a potential visit to Gwangju.


Q. Chairman Yongjin Chung mentioned, “I take full responsibility.” What does this mean?

A. The event by the E-commerce team was the decision of the affiliate’s CEO. However, what Chairman Chung means by “taking responsibility” is that, as the group chairman, he does not intend to avoid responsibility for this matter. Regardless of the investigation results, he will oversee all aspects, including measures to prevent recurrence and raising employees’ historical awareness, until this issue is resolved. Since a police investigation is ongoing, he will take responsibility for every aspect, including the results of that investigation.


Q. Three people who suggested the name ‘Tank’ in the investigation refused to submit their mobile phones. Why?

A. There were five employees who planned the event. Two of them submitted their mobile phones, stating they wanted to prove there was no intent behind the incident. The other three refused, citing privacy concerns. As a result, it was impossible to cross-verify all five directly involved employees, making it difficult to determine the truth about prior collusion.

However, based on the internal messenger conversations among these five individuals, it appears that when the 'Tank Day' name became controversial due to its association with a historical event, all five were visibly flustered. Internally, we believe that there was likely no prior conspiracy, but since we could not conduct forensics on the personal mobile phones, we cannot state this conclusively.


Q. This incident seems to reflect organizational culture. How do you assess the organizational culture, and what needs to change?

A. We reviewed all events held at Starbucks over the past 10 years. We could not confirm any events specifically targeting historic incidents such as the Sewol Ferry tragedy on April 16 or the May 18 Democratization Movement. This is because so many events are held every two weeks. Looking at the ages of the marketing staff, there are two in their early 20s and three in their early 30s, which may result in a somewhat different perspective on historical awareness. In the future, we plan to develop programs to foster proper historical awareness among employees, not only in their 20s but also up to those in their 60s.


Q. It is said that after this controversy, more than 60% of the balance must be used to get a refund on prepaid cards. Are there any plans to address this? What specific measures are being taken to prevent recurrence?

A. I understand that there have been requests not only for prepaid card refunds but also for withdrawal from our membership program. We will improve this in whatever way customers want. However, there is a legal agreement for gift certificates under the Fair Trade Commission’s regulations, called the Standard Terms and Conditions for New-type Gift Certificates, so we are in discussions with the relevant government ministries. Additionally, a system update is needed to handle refund requests on-site. We will continue to provide updates on this matter.


Regarding the internal approval process, there are usually four stages of approval for events. There is normally a CSR officer, but it was found that both the CSR and legal teams were excluded from this approval line. The E-commerce team organizes a large number of events, and one of the key points for reflection is that the marketing team focused solely on sales, overlooking the significance of event dates and their meanings. Approval was often given based on reviewing drafts, but it was confirmed that approvals were sometimes given out of habit. We are currently discussing how to systematically improve this process.


Q. Will there be any additional actions regarding the CSR team?

A. Further investigation is required. We are also developing measures to improve internal processes.


Q. This incident was approved through four stages of review. At the group level, do you see this as a matter of personal misconduct by one employee? What do you consider the main cause? How do you respond to criticism of scapegoating and politicization, and to the resurfacing of past remarks by the chairman?

A. This case demonstrates the shortcomings of the company’s internal control and risk management systems. Even if the event planner made a poor judgment, the proper processes should have filtered it out during the approval phase. If the company’s systems had functioned normally, this incident would not have occurred. The key to follow-up measures is how we improve this aspect. Acknowledging the seriousness, the company immediately dismissed CEO Jeon Son and the executive in charge of E-commerce on the same day. Additional accountability will be pursued based on further investigation results.


I would also like to reiterate that there is no connection between past remarks by the chairman and this Starbucks marketing promotion.


Q. What communication has there been with Starbucks U.S. headquarters regarding this incident? There are reports of discussions at the headquarters level.

A. The U.S. global headquarters is taking this matter very seriously. Starbucks believes its brand value stems from respecting the emotions and cultures of each region. We have shared all relevant developments, including employee actions and the investigation process, with headquarters since the incident occurred, and we continue to share all processes with them.


Q. President Jaemyung Lee and other government officials have mentioned Starbucks in relation to this controversy. Has there been any separate communication with the government or the Presidential Office?

A. There has been no separate communication with the government since the incident. Like everyone else, we are receiving relevant messages through news and media reports. However, we believe we must take responsibility for the mistakes in our marketing.


Q. Is an investigation or further discussion underway at the U.S. headquarters? Has there been any impact on sales following this incident?

A. We are sharing the overall situation with the headquarters. The headquarters also views this matter seriously and intends to discuss improvements to internal controls and processes. I understand that there will be an official consultation within a few days. Regarding the possibility of exercising the call option, I cannot comment at this time. While the contract does allow for the exercise of the call option in the event of attributable causes, we do not believe that this incident qualifies. The headquarters has not brought up this point, either.



In terms of business, there has indeed been a significant decrease in sales. However, I do not believe it is the time to focus on sales figures. Above all, we will do our utmost to apologize to and support those who have been hurt and affected by this incident.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing