[Lee Hyukwoo's Beyond the Frame] Perfect Documents, Deceptive Practices, Zero Effect... Formalism Dominates Korea
Safety Inspection Checklists and Meaningless High School Credit Schedules
Mandatory Training Watched on Mute at Double Speed
Unrealistic Plans, Disappointing Outcomes
The Futility of "Policy Games" and Hollow Justification
164
If the lines drawn by laws and policies are crossed too frequently, they become blurred. In extreme cases, they may even disappear altogether. When these lines become impossible to uphold or lose their effectiveness, "crossing the line" quickly becomes normalized. However, this does not mean that the line truly vanishes. Whenever the time comes to assign responsibility, it reappears clearly and holds violators accountable. The consequences can be harsher than expected. Sometimes, a simple fine may be the end of it. However, there are cases where one faces lawsuits or must endure more severe punishments.
Countless policies create the 'line of formality,' and repeatedly crossing it weakens the effect. Getty Images Bank
View original imageWe often find ourselves going out of our way to maintain these lines. Examples include high school credit system schedules that persist only as a formality with no real effect, safety inspections where checklists are completed with circles but little genuine attention is paid, mandatory legal education played on mute, and indicators created solely to receive favorable evaluations. All of these are inconvenient without delivering tangible results. Yet, on paper, they exist perfectly. This is their common denominator.
There was an incident at a waste treatment company in Busan where an explosion caused casualties due to mixing wastewater. After this accident, a new requirement was introduced: a full inspection before mixing wastewater. The idea was that pre-mixing inspections would prevent accidents. It seemed perfect at first. The law was enacted swiftly, but during the process of drafting enforcement ordinances, a fundamental flaw in this logic was revealed. Conducting a pre-inspection every time wastewater is mixed proved to be practically impossible. The cost of inspections was also a burden, but more importantly, since wastewater is inevitably mixed in various ways due to technical reasons, conducting inspections before mixing was criticized as a "contradiction in terms."
Interestingly, there are many ways to address such problems from a policy-technical perspective. Checklists and simplified inspections can be introduced, or inspection agenda items can be mobilized. In some cases, expensive evaluations that should cost millions of won are replaced with simple visual checks, citing budget constraints. It is hard to find a rigid civil servant at the scene who would demand strict adherence to the original procedures. They all know that strictly following every regulation would make it impossible to get the work done. Administrative techniques, in this sense, are sometimes artistic, but at the same time, they are also merely formal.
There are reasons why these irrationalities, prevalent across the country, are so difficult to eliminate. Both citizens who are required to comply and civil servants who conduct inspections repeatedly bow their heads under the pretext that "things will improve if we just do this." The government, intoxicated with the ideal of "creating a better world," often imposes regulations that would be impossible for its own officials to follow, yet demands compliance from the public. For every backlash, there are just as many citizens who applaud and welcome these measures. Gradually, all questions about such irrationalities fade away. As this cycle repeats, formalism within our society has never been properly cleared away and has only accumulated over time.
The "paradox of planning" is also at work. For example, everyone has made plans to improve their grades, only to find that the plans were so detailed that they were impossible to follow. Unsustainable plans inevitably result in disappointing report cards. Yet paradoxically, we respond by making even more detailed plans afterward. We may even feel a sense of satisfaction at these new, even less attainable schedules. As long as we believe that simply following a plan will lead to improvement, we do not bother to ask ourselves, "Why are we doing this?" Eventually, schedules cut into sleeping time and become mired in formalism. This paradox has become widespread, not just personally, but throughout our society.
There is also a deeply ingrained misconception. Whenever a problem arises, we tend to blame individuals, not the system. For example, convenience store owners are criticized for finding ways to ensure that student part-timers do not work more than 15 hours a week to avoid paying weekly holiday allowances. Small business owners are often condemned for laying off non-regular workers every two years to avoid converting them to regular employees. Whenever a sexual harassment incident occurs at an institution, the first thing checked is whether the mandatory pre-training was completed. As soon as failures are exposed, those involved become nationwide targets for criticism. When it is time to assign responsibility or find a scapegoat, formalism becomes a convenient tool.
This kind of blame is problematic in many ways. The focus needs to shift. We must look for the root causes in the system, not in individuals. The origin of formalism lies in abnormal systems. When rules are flawed, they are clearly unreasonable and ineffective to everyone. Yet they must still be followed, causing suffering. This is why the phrase "law-abiding struggle" exists. The contradiction of struggling while following the rules is self-explanatory. It implies that there are problems within the laws and systems being followed during the struggle. Such systems must be fixed without delay. Convenience store owners and small business CEOs must survive by turning a profit in a challenging business environment, regardless of regulations. We all know that mandatory workplace sexual harassment prevention training played on mute is a meaningless formality.
On the 22nd of last month, Jongseob Shim, Director of the National Affairs Coordination Office at the Office for Government Policy Coordination, is briefing the first task of the National Normalization Project at the Government Seoul Office in Jongno-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency
View original imageIt was only last month that the government announced 164 tasks under the "National Normalization Project," vowing to quietly correct entrenched irrationalities and expedient practices. This is a welcome step, but bolder action is needed to address formalism within our society. For such nationwide campaigns, a single question is sufficient: "Why are we doing this?" We should compile a list of laws and systems that correspond to this question. Before coming up with countermeasures, we must first determine whether the situation really warrants one. At some point, whenever an accident occurs, a countermeasure is quickly established, and these countermeasures only deepen formalism in a vicious cycle. The numerous measures designed to make classrooms safer have, in the end, led to the loss of teachers' authority to the extent that even experiential learning is now avoided—another manifestation of this vicious cycle.
The so-called "full investigation" used as a collective disciplinary tool must also be reformed. When an incident occurs at an institution, orders from the president or related ministers quickly lead to investigations of all similar institutions, inevitably devolving into a process of filling out "formal" survey forms. Above all, to resolve the formalism within us, citizens, the National Assembly, and the government must all put an end to "mental victory policy games." Clinging to actions done for the sake of a good cause, even when no one understands why, is nothing more than a self-satisfying delusion.
We live in an era where even the president advocates for pragmatism. Now more than ever, the government must let go of its obsession with doing something for the sake of doing something. Instead of creating new irrational rules that give rise to formalism, we must focus our efforts on eliminating unnecessary systems from within.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Lee Hyukwoo, Professor of Public Administration at Paichai University (Chairman of the Regulation Monitoring Committee at the Good Regulation Citizens Forum)
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.