"If That's the Case, I Should Have Joined Memory" Internal Discord Deepens at Samsung... Even Talk of a Foundry Spin-Off
Samsung Electronics Labor-Management Incentive Vote Underway
Complaints Over Incentive Gap for Employees “Transferred from Memory”
Management Insists on Principle of Performance-Based Pay
Some in Industry Suggest “Non-Memory Spin-Off
While a vote among union members on the performance-based compensation agreement between labor and management at Samsung Electronics is underway, controversy over bonuses discrepancies between business divisions shows no sign of abating. Dissatisfaction is mounting over the concentration of bonuses in the memory business division, and as internal conflict continues, some in and outside the industry are going so far as to raise the idea of spinning off the non-memory division.
Samsung Electronics building in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the 26th, one day before the deadline for the approval vote on the tentative agreement for the 2026 wage and collective bargaining agreement. Photo by Yonhap News Agency
View original imageAccording to industry sources on May 26, after reaching a tentative agreement, labor and management at Samsung Electronics are holding a vote among union members until 10 a.m. on May 27. As of 10:17 a.m. on the fifth day of voting, more than 51,835 members of the super-enterprise union had participated, with a turnout exceeding 90%. Industry observers believe that since over 80% of the super-enterprise union members belong to the Device Solutions (DS) division, approval is highly likely.
However, internal backlash over bonus discrepancies between divisions has only intensified since the tentative agreement was made public. According to the agreement, employees in the DS division’s memory business are expected to receive up to 600 million won in bonuses, while the non-memory business unit, which is operating at a loss, is estimated to receive only around 100 million won.
An employee from Samsung Electronics’ foundry (semiconductor contract manufacturing) business division commented on the controversy surrounding the tentative performance-based compensation agreement, stating, “There is discontent on the ground that, even though we’re all part of the DS division, the gap in bonuses is just too large. Under the pretext of saving the foundry, tens of thousands of employees have been forcibly transferred or reassigned from the memory division, and the disparity among them is excessive.” Employees who were reassigned from the memory department to expand the foundry and system LSI (non-memory) divisions in the past now feel they are being unfairly treated due to the bonus differences.
Within the DS division, there is a sense of relative deprivation due to frequent personnel movements between memory and non-memory units. Originally, Samsung Electronics’ semiconductor business consisted solely of memory, and foundry and system LSI were created as separate divisions to foster the system semiconductor business, meaning they share the same roots. Especially amid poor industry conditions, voices are emerging that memory division staff, who are being reassigned to foundry and system LSI, should be treated as part of the same business unit in practice.
Another employee from the memory division said, “Honestly, I just got lucky in the lottery,” and added, “I don’t think there’s any significant difference in ability between memory and foundry (non-memory) employees,” expressing some empathy for the grievances of non-memory staff. He also conveyed concerns within the non-memory division that, “If it continues like this, everyone will just want to move to memory.” He self-deprecatingly remarked, “If this leads to the opening of ‘job posting’ (an internal talent recruitment system), everyone will apply for it.”
Management, however, has maintained that it does not align with the principles of meritocracy to reward business units with significant contributions to performance and those running deficits by the same standard. The industry consensus is also that, given the nature of performance-based bonuses, higher-performing departments should be more highly rewarded. An industry official said, “During the initial incubation period, it was true that, even if there were no tangible results, everyone would share the excess profit incentive (OPI) as a common semiconductor metric and help grow the business. But now, the incubation period is over, and it’s time to deliver real results.”
Against this backdrop, internal union conflicts are escalating into legal disputes. The third union, Samsung Electronics Labor Union Companion (Donghaeng Union), which withdrew from the joint struggle headquarters, filed for a court injunction at Suwon District Court at 9 a.m. to stop the voting procedures on the labor-management agreement. The Donghaeng Union, mainly representing device experience (DX) employees, argues that the current agreement was pushed forward with a focus on DS employees and that there was not enough input from other parties. In response, a Samsung Electronics official said, “We hope that the vision of being able to receive more bonuses when results are delivered will serve as a strong motivational factor, and we will consider additional measures step by step going forward.”
Industry analysis suggests that this controversy is also linked to Samsung Electronics’ business structure. Among the world’s top semiconductor companies, Samsung Electronics is effectively the only integrated device manufacturer (IDM) to operate both memory and non-memory businesses. SK hynix and Micron focus on memory, while TSMC is centered on foundry operations. Samsung Electronics has maintained that its structure, operating both memory and non-memory businesses, has allowed it to respond to market fluctuations and secure technological synergy.
As internal strife continues, calls for the spin-off of the foundry business are re-emerging within the industry. For some time, there have been consistent arguments, especially from the non-memory—particularly the foundry—division, that spinning off would enhance specialization, but persistent large-scale losses have made its independent survival seem unlikely. However, with Samsung Foundry now seeing increased orders from big tech companies due to growing demand for artificial intelligence (AI) semiconductors, the possibility of returning to profitability as early as the second quarter of this year is being discussed.
Industry experts believe that if the foundry business becomes independent, it could more actively attract global fabless (semiconductor design specialist) clients such as Nvidia, AMD, and Qualcomm, and establish a separate investment and revenue structure from the memory business. Shin Hyuncheol, professor in the Department of Semiconductor Systems Engineering at Kwangwoon University, said, “In the past, Samsung Electronics’ memory and foundry businesses supported each other and grew, much like today’s relationship between MediaTek and TSMC. But if division-level conflicts become entrenched, it could affect the company’s overall growth. If symbiosis between divisions becomes difficult, talk of separation will definitely arise.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Kim Yongseok, distinguished professor at Gachon University’s College of Semiconductors, also stressed, “If the foundry and fabless (system LSI) businesses are left as they are, there is a high risk they could wither away. To resolve this issue, the spin-off should be pursued after more aggressive investment leads to profitability.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.