Only 8.8 Million Won Recognized Out of 18.7 Million Won for Three Cases

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Supreme Court has ruled that a lawyer's act of signing separate contracts and receiving separate fees for multiple civil and criminal cases with overlapping basic facts constitutes a violation of the principle of good faith.


According to the legal community on May 26, the Supreme Court's First Division (Presiding Justice Seo Kyunghwan) dismissed the appeal and upheld the original ruling in a damages claim appeal filed by client A against Law Firm B and its affiliated attorney C.


Previously, in 2022, after purchasing a building with defects such as leaks and noise, A began preparing legal action against the seller and the certified real estate agent. A entered into a contract with Law Firm B, commissioning three tasks in total: a civil lawsuit for damages against the seller, a criminal complaint for fraud against the agent, and a separate criminal complaint for fraud against the seller. In this process, A paid the law firm a total of 18.7 million won as a retainer fee.


Subsequently, the civil case was finalized by a mediation recommendation decision, under which A was to receive 30 million won. However, the seller did not comply with this decision, and the criminal complaints were closed with non-prosecution dispositions.


A then filed a lawsuit, claiming that the attorney in charge had violated their duty to explain, performed their work in a negligent manner, and intentionally split up cases that could have been handled together in order to collect overlapping fees, demanding a refund of the legal fees as well as compensation for damages.



The court of first instance dismissed all of A's claims. However, the appellate court determined that the appropriate fee for all three cases combined should be 8.8 million won and ordered Law Firm B to return the excess amount of 9.9 million won to A. The court found that receiving 18.7 million won by separately accepting civil and criminal cases with overlapping facts and evidence violated the principle of good faith and fairness. However, the claim against attorney C, who was not a party to the contract, was dismissed.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing