Consumer Groups Demand Unconditional Full Refunds

The amount of prepaid deposits held by Starbucks Korea has increased by more than 8% over the past year, surpassing 420 billion won. However, concerns about a regulatory gap are mounting, as the company is not subject to direct oversight or supervision by financial authorities. Recently, controversy over the 'Tank Day' event prompted consumer groups to demand unconditional full refunds, intensifying debate over the refund rules for prepaid funds and the overall supervisory system.


According to the Starbucks Korea audit report on May 24, as of the end of last year, Starbucks' prepaid funds amounted to 427.56 billion won, an increase of 32.5 billion won (8.22%) from the previous year. Prepaid funds refer to amounts that consumers have charged in advance to the Starbucks app or prepaid card.


The issue is that despite holding consumer funds worth hundreds of billions of won, Starbucks Korea operates outside the regulatory framework of the financial authorities. Under the current Electronic Financial Transactions Act, only payment methods that can be used at third-party merchants, other than the issuer, are defined as prepaid electronic payment means. Since Starbucks operates all its stores directly and the issuer and point of use are the same, the law classifies it as a 'single store.' As a result, unlike registered prepaid service providers such as Naver Pay and Kakao Pay, Starbucks is not subject to financial authorities' supervision.

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

In effect, Starbucks' prepaid funds are treated in the same category as advance payments at a local restaurant. Nevertheless, some point out that the scale of these funds now rivals that of small financial service providers. According to materials submitted to the Financial Supervisory Service and others by Kang Min-guk, a member of the People Power Party, Starbucks has operated its prepaid deposits as cash-equivalent assets, such as deposits and trusts, since 2020 and has earned approximately 40.8 billion won in interest income.


The refund regulations for prepaid funds are also a point of controversy. The terms and conditions for Starbucks cards stipulate that more than 60% of the balance must be used before a refund can be requested. This adheres to the Fair Trade Commission's 'Standard Terms and Conditions for New-Type Gift Certificates,' under which gift certificates valued at 10,000 won or less require at least 80% usage for a refund. Consumer groups argue that it is unreasonable to apply the same standard even when a boycott occurs due to a company's wrongdoing.


The controversy was sparked by Starbucks' so-called 'Tank Day' event. On May 18, Starbucks conducted a tumbler promotion using phrases such as 'Tank Day' and 'On the Desk.' Online, critics argued that these expressions evoke memories of the 5·18 Democratization Movement and the torture and death of activist Park Jong-chul, leading to boycott movements among some consumers.

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Currently, Starbucks' prepaid funds are governed by the Electronic Commerce Act under the jurisdiction of the Fair Trade Commission. This law stipulates that at least 10% of prepaid funds must be insured by a guarantee insurance policy. Starbucks has insured 94.1% of its prepaid funds—about 402.4 billion won—through Seoul Guarantee Insurance (SGI). However, approximately 25.1 billion won are not covered by the insurance, and the details of fund management are not disclosed in detail.



On May 22, the Korea Consumer Federation issued a statement urging Starbucks to refund the entire remaining balance unconditionally to consumers who no longer wish to use its services. The Federation further argued that when a boycott results from a company's clear wrongdoing, the relevant terms and systems should be improved to allow consumers to receive a refund of their prepaid funds regardless of the amount used.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing