POSCO E&C’s ‘CD-1% Interest Rate and 200 Million Won Financial Support’
Controversy Over Potential Violation of the Urban Renewal Act Raises Concerns in Contractor Selection
Seocho District Office Requests Authoritative Interpretation from Ministry of Land
Company Explains: “The Financing Eases Project Cost Burden, Support Funds Are Structured as Loans”

It has been confirmed that the Seocho District Office in Seoul has requested an authoritative interpretation from the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport regarding POSCO E&C's proposed financing terms for project costs during the selection process for the Shinbanpo 19·25 Reconstruction construction contractor. The office sought to determine whether POSCO E&C's proposal to secure approximately 190 billion won in essential project costs at an interest rate 1 percentage point lower than the certificate of deposit (CD) rate might violate the Urban Renewal Act. If found to be illegal, this could lead to disqualification from participating in the bidding process. Although the scale of the Shinbanpo 19·25 Reconstruction project is relatively modest, with a total construction cost of 443.4 billion won, the symbolic significance of bidding for a Gangnam-area project means that the selection procedure is expected to have a broad impact.


According to the maintenance industry on the 23rd, the Seocho District Office recently asked the Ministry of Land for an authoritative interpretation on whether POSCO E&C's proposed project cost financing terms for the Shinbanpo 19·25 Reconstruction Association could potentially violate the Urban Renewal Act. An official from the Seocho District Office stated, "There was a divergence in legal interpretation among stakeholders regarding the project cost terms," adding, "If the association takes any independent action before the Ministry of Land's interpretation is issued, the legal responsibility lies with the association."

"Project Cost Financing at CD Rate Minus 1%?"...Local Government Requests Authoritative Interpretation on Banpo Reconstruction View original image

The main issues in question are the project cost financing rate and the provision of tens of millions of won in financial support per household. POSCO E&C proposed to secure 190 billion won in essential project costs at an interest rate 1 percentage point lower than the CD rate, which currently stands at around 1.82% per annum. Project costs refer to expenditures excluding construction costs and are divided into essential project costs related to overall construction and project promotion expenses such as additional relocation funds and rental deposit returns, which are not directly related to construction. POSCO E&C plans to secure the 553 billion won in project promotion expenses, excluding essential project costs, at the lowest interest rate through competitive bidding from financial institutions.


The proposed financial support of 200 million won per household has also come under scrutiny. POSCO E&C proposed to provide a total of 89.2 billion won in financial support, distributing 200 million won to each association member. In the company’s promotional materials, it was explained to association members that "the company will deposit its own cash into members' accounts, which can be used as additional relocation funds or for relocation loan interest support."


Some observers have raised concerns that these terms may violate the Urban Renewal Act. According to Article 132 of the Act and its enforcement decree, construction contractors are prohibited from providing money or property benefits unrelated to construction. Excessive financial incentives offered during the bidding process may be interpreted as de facto provision of valuables that could influence members’ votes.

Model of POSCO E&C The Banpo OTIER. Photo by Lee Ji-eun

Model of POSCO E&C The Banpo OTIER. Photo by Lee Ji-eun

View original image

The Ministry of Land has begun reviewing the authoritative interpretation. A Ministry official explained, "If it is determined that there is a potential violation, the city or provincial governor must notify the project implementer of a restriction on bidding participation in accordance with Article 113 of the Urban Renewal Act, and the association receiving such notice must restrict the contractor’s bidding eligibility."


The company maintains that its proposal does not constitute a legal violation. A POSCO E&C representative explained, "The CD-1% interest rate is a financing arrangement for essential project costs related to construction and is a financial support measure to reduce the association's project cost burden." The 200 million won in financial support per household is also characterized as a loan rather than a cash handout. The structure is designed to advance the association’s future profits, which are maximized through mechanisms such as confirmed post-sale and deferred construction cost payments, and is not intended to provide association members with free benefits.



However, the specific repayment methods and interest rate terms have not yet been clearly presented. POSCO E&C has stated that the final interest rate and payment method for the financial support will be determined through a resolution at the association’s general meeting. Kim Yerim, managing attorney at Law Firm Simmok, commented, "If the 200 million won is provided as a project cost loan, there should be no problem," but added, "However, if interest is not actually collected or the structure provides members with substantial financial benefits, it would constitute a violation."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing