61.8% Say "Intentional Historical Disparagement"... 75.5% Plan to "Use Less"

Starbucks Marketing Controversy Shakes Brand Trust and Consumer Behavior

A citizen standing in front of Starbucks. Photo by Yonhap News

A citizen standing in front of Starbucks. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

As controversy continues surrounding Starbucks Korea's so-called "Tank Day" promotion held on the anniversary of the May 18 Democratization Movement—accused of distorting history and insulting victims—a majority of consumers perceive this incident not as a simple mistake, but as a case of "intentional historical disparagement." Public opinion on Starbucks' subsequent response, such as apologies and personnel changes, was generally critical, and it was also confirmed that this issue is having a significant impact on actual consumer behavior.


Previously, on the 18th, Starbucks Korea came under fire for its tumbler promotion using the name "Tank Day" along with phrases such as "May 18th" and "Desk Bang." Critics pointed out that "tank" evokes the armored vehicles used by martial law troops during the May 18 Democratization Movement, while "desk bang" is reminiscent of the Park Jongcheol torture and death case.


According to a survey conducted online by The Asia Business Daily on the 21st and 22nd, 61.8% of respondents answered that the recent Starbucks marketing controversy was "intentional historical disparagement." Including those who responded with "serious historical ignorance" (24.5%), 86.3% of all respondents viewed the issue as stemming from either intent or ignorance, rather than a simple mistake. Only 14 people (12.7%) considered it a "mere coincidence."


Survey results on "What do you think about the recent Starbucks marketing controversy?" conducted online by The Asia Business Daily from the 21st to the 22nd of this month. Photo by Chunghoon Park

Survey results on "What do you think about the recent Starbucks marketing controversy?" conducted online by The Asia Business Daily from the 21st to the 22nd of this month. Photo by Chunghoon Park

View original image

"They apologized, but it wasn't enough"... Evaluation: Insufficient Recovery of Trust

Public opinion was also more critical regarding the follow-up actions taken by Shinsegae Group, including their apology and replacement of the CEO. More than half (57.3%) of respondents stated that the measures were "insufficient," while only 31.8% considered them "appropriate." Just 10.9% thought the response was "excessive." This suggests that many believe explanations regarding the background and responsibility for the controversy were still lacking, despite the apology and personnel changes.


"Will Use Less" 75%... Even 'Talbeok' Movement Emerges

A negative shift was also observed in consumers’ intentions to use the brand. When asked about their "intention to use Starbucks after this incident," 75.5% of respondents said they would "use it less." Only 20.9% answered "no change," while just 3.6% said they would "use it more."


This indicates that the issue is having a direct impact on brand loyalty and consumer choices, beyond being a one-off controversy. In fact, a so-called "Talbeok" (Starbucks boycott) movement is spreading online, with people pledging to discard products or refrain from visiting stores.


Critical perspectives were prominent in open-ended responses as well. Some stated, "It's hard to see this as a mistake," and "They crossed the line," while others questioned, "Isn't it possible that the owner's message and organizational culture led to a marketing risk?" However, there were also some cautious opinions, such as "We must avoid excessive interpretation" and "There are concerns about franchisee losses."



Meanwhile, as refund requests from consumers increased due to this controversy, it has been confirmed that Starbucks issued a notice to store staff to familiarize themselves with the refund manual. A Starbucks representative stated, "We notified all stores nationwide to ensure smooth guidance for customer inquiries."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing