Bonus Disputes Are Likely to Recur

[Reporter’s Notebook] Time to Consider Fair Profit Sharing View original image

The labor union of Samsung Electronics reached a tentative agreement with management on the brink of a strike, but now faces a significant hurdle: a wave of negative public opinion. The public criticizes the Samsung Electronics union for demanding what is seen as an excessive share of company profits. Furthermore, as unions at other major corporations such as Kakao, HD Hyundai Heavy Industries, and LG Uplus also demand compensation, Samsung Electronics is likely to be viewed as the starting point for a possible chain reaction of strikes. Although the Samsung Electronics union achieved its demands by threatening to halt operations at semiconductor factories, it expended a substantial amount of public goodwill in the process. This represents a new form of the "winner's curse."


However, the fact that other major corporate unions are moving toward disputes despite the negative public opinion directed at Samsung Electronics is worth careful consideration. The key issue is the fairness of profit sharing. The Kakao union has argued that, despite the company achieving record-high earnings and executives being allocated short-term incentives amounting to 150% of their salaries, the pool for employee bonuses was reduced. The unions at LG Uplus and HD Hyundai Heavy Industries are each demanding that 30% of operating profit be distributed as bonuses. The typical slogans once seen in union movements—such as "safe workplaces," "no overwork," or occasional political slogans—are absent. Put simply, the message is that if the company earns more, employees should also be paid more.


The mainstream arguments of the past will not resonate with this new type of union. As the proportion of younger generations increases among major corporate unions, their primary concern is solely fair profit distribution. While management may argue that it is necessary to accumulate resources for the company's future growth, the younger generation does not feel bound to their companies. If necessary, they can simply leave. The logic of major labor federations—that profits should be shared with subcontracted workers—also fails to persuade them. They seek to be compensated in proportion to their own contributions, and as long as employees in similar positions at comparable companies are treated similarly, that is sufficient.


Before the demands for profit sharing by major corporate unions encountered resistance, society was briefly intoxicated by economic performance. The KOSPI surged past 7,000 points in an instant, and despite the U.S.-Iran war, both total exports and semiconductor exports hit all-time highs. The ruling party credited the current administration, while the opposition criticized the results as being concentrated in a handful of companies—but neither denied the record-breaking numbers. The issue of how profits should be distributed naturally follows such results, but when Kim Yongbeom, the Blue House policy chief, mentioned a "national dividend," the conversation quickly devolved into irrelevant debates about fake news and communism. Struggles over bonuses, like that at the Samsung Electronics union, are likely to recur in the future.



Now is the time to consider how to ensure fair profit sharing. First, it is necessary to determine an appropriate level for the distribution of profits. Excessive demands from unions risk having a negative impact on the entire industry. Conversely, if management is reluctant to distribute profits, it will face the challenge of losing talent to other companies. Consideration must also be given to how to communicate and resolve union demands. Unions should avoid resorting to violent tactics, and management should not simply ignore union demands. In this sense, the fact that Samsung Electronics management and union resolved their issues through dialogue, rather than allowing the situation to deteriorate, is symbolic. Both sides must adapt to this changing environment.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing