Vote on Tentative Agreement from May 22 to 27

Backlash over “Memory-Centric” Bonus Structure

High Likelihood of Passage with DS Making Up 80% of Union

Shareholders Also Demand “Approval at General Meeting”

Samsung Electronics and its labor union, having averted the risk of a strike, now face the final hurdle in wage negotiations. The tentative agreement must be approved through a wage agreement vote to become final, but there remains significant backlash due to sharp differences between divisions such as semiconductor and non-semiconductor, as well as memory and non-memory sectors.


The Samsung Electronics labor union will hold a vote on the tentative agreement from 2 p.m. on May 22 until 10 a.m. on May 27. Eligible voters are union members listed as of 2 p.m. the previous day, and the vote will be conducted electronically. If more than half of the union members participate and a majority votes in favor, the agreement will be approved; if not, it will be rejected.


Ahead of the vote, internal responses are divided by business division. Employees in the Device Solutions (DS) division's memory business unit, which constitutes a large portion of the Samsung Group's super-enterprise union members who led the strike initiative, are reportedly satisfied as they are expected to receive a special management performance bonus estimated at 600 million won per person. On the other hand, in the non-memory (foundry and system LSI) business units, discontent is surfacing as the expected distribution per person is 162 million won.


The Fate of Samsung's Labor Agreement: Memory Division Support Remains Strong, But Non-Memory and Shareholder Discontent Persists View original image

Employees in the Device eXperience (DX) division, responsible for smartphones, TVs, and home appliances, are protesting the agreement. Although the agreement includes a compensation and benefits plan—such as company stock worth about 6 million won—for both the DX division and the CSS business team, DX employees claim that their demands were not reflected.


However, the likelihood of rejection is considered low. The DS division accounts for 88% of the super-enterprise union, which holds the majority. The Samsung Electronics Labor Union Donghaeng (Donghaeng Union, with about 12,300 members), which has a high proportion of DX division members, withdrew from the joint struggle headquarters in protest against the negotiation process. Effectively, the DS division's sentiment is expected to determine whether the agreement is approved.


Given public concern over potential production disruptions due to a strike, there is a prevailing sentiment that an agreement must be reached. If the agreement is rejected, there is a high likelihood that the entire union executive team leading the wage negotiations and strike efforts will resign, raising concerns about the absence of suitable replacements to lead future wage negotiations.


"Sense of Deprivation" and "Forced Transfer Unfairness"—DX and Non-Memory Employees Voice Complaints

Photo of Samsung Electronics headquarters in Suwon, Gyeonggi Province on the 22nd. Photo by Yonhap News.

Photo of Samsung Electronics headquarters in Suwon, Gyeonggi Province on the 22nd. Photo by Yonhap News.

View original image

Regardless of whether the agreement passes, aftershocks are expected to continue. There is a noticeable drop in morale within the DX division. One 15-year veteran employee in the DX division stated, "Hearing that memory business unit staff could receive more than 600 million won has caused an extreme sense of relative deprivation. Even though we work under the same roof, the widening gap in compensation has demoralized us and diminished our motivation to work."


Even within the DS division—the biggest beneficiary—there is an outpouring of dissatisfaction from the non-memory business units such as foundry. A junior employee in the foundry business unit explained, "Due to the nature of semiconductors, memory and non-memory are organically connected and cannot be separated with a knife. In the case of high-bandwidth memory (HBM), the essential base die is produced by the foundry business unit and supplied to the memory business unit at nearly cost, with virtually no margin."


They also pointed out that the foundry business unit inevitably posts chronic accounting deficits because enormous facility investment costs and depreciation expenses are concentrated there. Many employees who have been forcibly transferred from the memory business unit to the foundry business unit also feel unfairly treated.


Shareholders Say "Shareholder Approval Required at General Meeting"

Minkyung Kwon, Representative of the Korea Shareholders Movement Headquarters, is holding a press conference announcing a shareholder letter for Samsung Electronics in front of the Korea Securities Depository in Yeouido, Seoul, on the 18th. Photo by Yonhap News.

Minkyung Kwon, Representative of the Korea Shareholders Movement Headquarters, is holding a press conference announcing a shareholder letter for Samsung Electronics in front of the Korea Securities Depository in Yeouido, Seoul, on the 18th. Photo by Yonhap News.

View original image

The Korea Shareholders Movement Headquarters, a shareholder group, will hold a press conference in front of the Supreme Court in the afternoon to release a public statement demanding the cancellation of the agreement and the adoption of profit-based compensation. The group argues that the tentative agreement linking and allocating performance bonuses in advance based on 12% of pre-tax operating profit is illegal and has announced plans for legal action.



In particular, they insist that a general meeting of shareholders should be convened to obtain shareholder approval before finalizing the agreement and have announced a lawsuit for next month. Minkyung Kwon, head of the Korea Shareholders Movement Headquarters, said, "The lawsuit is intended to point out the problem with proceeding only through a union vote and board resolution on a matter that should obviously go through a general meeting of shareholders. If shareholders approve, we will not oppose the agreement."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing