"Difficult to Conclude That Definitive Judgments Were Provided on Uncertain Situations"

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Supreme Court has finalized a ruling that the financial authorities must cancel the sanctions, including the "partial suspension of business," imposed on NH Investment & Securities in connection with the Optimus Fund scandal.


According to the legal community on the 22nd, the First Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Shin Sook-hee) upheld the previous court ruling in favor of NH Investment & Securities in a lawsuit filed against the Financial Services Commission and the Governor of the Financial Supervisory Service, seeking to cancel the partial suspension of business and other sanctions.


The Optimus scandal, which came to light in 2020, involved Optimus Asset Management attracting investors by claiming to invest in accounts receivable guaranteed by public institutions and local governments, but instead investing in private bonds of insolvent companies, causing damage of over 400 billion won. NH Investment & Securities was the largest distributor of the Optimus Fund, which had suspended redemptions.


In March 2022, the financial authorities imposed sanctions on NH Investment & Securities, stating that the company violated its obligation to prohibit improper solicitation under the Capital Markets Act while selling the Optimus Fund. Article 49, paragraph 2 of the Capital Markets Act prohibits financial investment businesses from providing definitive judgments or conveying information that could be misunderstood as certain regarding uncertain matters during investment solicitation.


The Financial Services Commission imposed a three-month partial suspension of business on NH Investment & Securities, and the Financial Supervisory Service Governor issued a reprimand request for the employees involved. NH Investment & Securities filed an administrative lawsuit in response. In July 2023, the court of first instance ruled in favor of NH Investment & Securities, ordering all sanctions by the financial authorities to be canceled.


The first-instance court stated, "Although the plaintiff may not have fully fulfilled its duty of investor caution, it is difficult to conclude that the company engaged in 'providing definitive judgments on uncertain situations,' which was the basis for the sanctions." The court determined that the actual composition of the fund's investment assets was not necessarily uncertain, nor could it be said that NH Investment & Securities provided a 'definitive judgment' by expecting that the investment assets would include private bonds in addition to accounts receivable guaranteed by public institutions.



Although the financial authorities appealed, both the appellate court and the Supreme Court found no error in the lower court's judgment and dismissed the appeal. Previously, Jeong Young-chae, the former CEO of NH Investment & Securities, also won a final ruling last month in a lawsuit seeking to cancel a reprimand warning sanction imposed by the Financial Services Commission.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing