Shareholders' Group: "Allocating 12% of Pre-Tax Operating Profit Is Illegal"

"We Will File for Damages If Strike Resumes"

The Korea Shareholders' Movement Headquarters, a shareholders' group of Samsung Electronics, declared on May 21 that it would initiate legal proceedings, defining the tentative agreement on performance bonuses between management and labor at Samsung Electronics as "illegal."

Minkyung Kwon, head of the Shareholders' Action Headquarters, held a press conference on the 18th in front of the Korea Securities Depository in Yeouido, Seoul, to announce a shareholder letter for Samsung Electronics. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Minkyung Kwon, head of the Shareholders' Action Headquarters, held a press conference on the 18th in front of the Korea Securities Depository in Yeouido, Seoul, to announce a shareholder letter for Samsung Electronics. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

In a press release issued the same day, the Korea Shareholders' Movement Headquarters stated, "The labor-management agreement, which links and allocates 12% of pre-tax operating profit, violates the mandatory provisions of the Commercial Act and constitutes a 'disguised illegal dividend.' We will file an injunction to suspend the effect and a lawsuit to confirm invalidity as soon as the labor and management sign the collective agreement."


The Shareholders' Movement Headquarters also put pressure on both management and the labor union, citing President Lee Jaemyung's remarks at a cabinet meeting the previous day. President Lee had strongly criticized the union's demands at the time, stating, "Allocating a certain percentage of operating profit before taxes are deducted is something that even investors cannot do. It is shareholders who are entitled to profit distribution." Based on President Lee's comments and current law, the Shareholders' Movement Headquarters presented the "three-step principle" governing the distribution order of a corporation's operating profits: priority of taxes, capital soundness, and attribution to shareholders.



They argued, "Although the tentative agreement has made some progress by taking the form of 'payment of treasury shares after tax,' in essence, it is still structured to pre-calculate and allocate a certain percentage (12%) of pre-tax operating profit. This directly violates the principles of tax priority and capital soundness."

"Profit Distribution Without Shareholders’ Approval Is Invalid"... Samsung Electronics Shareholder Group Announces Lawsuit Over 'Provisional Agreement' View original image

Regarding the possibility of a strike following the rejection of the tentative agreement in a union vote, the group added that it would file a lawsuit seeking damages if a strike takes place. The Shareholders' Movement Headquarters stated, "Any industrial action resumed after the rejection that aims at distributing business profits rather than improving working conditions such as wages constitutes an 'illegal strike' and is an abuse of the three fundamental labor rights. If a strike materializes, we will file a lawsuit claiming damages for infringement of rights against all union executive members and individual members who actively participate in the strike, seeking compensation for losses resulting from production disruptions, decreased sales, declines in stock price, and reduced dividend resources."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing