Automatic Linkage and Removal of Caps: Push for Fixed Bonuses
Debate Over Whether Bonus Demands Are a Legitimate Labor Dispute
Lee: “Demand for Fixed Distribution of Operating Profit Goes Beyond Common Sense”

The controversy over performance bonuses, which began at SK hynix, has spread across the industry following the agreement at Samsung Electronics, with growing demands for the 'standardization of performance bonuses'.


The demand to automatically allocate a fixed percentage of operating profit as performance bonuses, which started in the semiconductor sector, is now expanding to the automobile, shipbuilding, IT, and bio industries. This has raised concerns that performance-based bonuses—which should fluctuate depending on results—could effectively become a second base salary. Furthermore, as the so-called "Yellow Envelope Law" takes effect, even subcontractor unions are demanding the same level of bonuses as those of the primary contractors, raising concerns that the entire wage system could be destabilized.


Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

On May 21, a review of the widespread demands across the industry shows that proposals such as 'N% of operating profit', 'automatic linkage of performance bonuses', and 'removal of bonus caps' are being put forward. These are intended to effectively mandate the standardization of performance bonuses, which, in principle, should be distributed according to performance.


If the practice of paying a fixed amount every year regardless of actual results becomes entrenched, it will be difficult to reduce bonuses during times of poor performance. There is also the burden that performance bonuses may be included in the calculation of the average wage, which serves as the basis for severance pay. This is why there have been calls for labor and management to clearly agree on the criteria for performance bonus payments.


The demand for performance bonuses based on a set portion of operating profit or net profit is spreading across industries during wage negotiations. The Hyundai Motor Union has submitted this year’s demands to management, including a monthly base salary increase of 149,600 won (excluding step increases), payment of a performance bonus equal to 30% of last year’s net profit, and guarantees of employment and working conditions related to artificial intelligence (AI). Management's position is that the criteria for paying performance bonuses are unclear, and that these criteria should be proactively discussed.


For the first time this year, the integrated union at HD Hyundai Heavy Industries has included demands for 'fair distribution of at least 30% of operating profit' in its wage increase proposal. There is also a growing number of unions at companies such as Hanwha Aerospace and HD Hyundai Electric calling for the abolition of performance bonus caps and broader reforms to the bonus system.

'N% Performance Bonus' Domino Starts in Semiconductors... Surge in Demands from Automotive, Shipbuilding, IT, and Bio Industries View original image

The POSCO union, also citing issues such as direct employment of partner company staff and wage system reform, has applied for mediation by the National Labor Relations Commission, raising the possibility of the first strike in the company’s history.


In the IT and bio industries, concerns over strikes are also materializing. The Kakao union, which has proposed automatic linkage of performance bonuses to approximately 13% of operating profit, approved a strike in a vote held on May 20. The Samsung Biologics union demanded that 20% of annual operating profit be permanently allocated for performance bonuses and went on a full-scale strike from May 1 to May 5.


The Yellow Envelope Law has further fueled bonus-related conflicts across subcontractors and partner companies. Subcontractor and partner company unions at SK hynix and HD Hyundai Heavy Industries are demanding the same level of bonuses as those received by the primary contractors.


Business leaders warn that allocating operating profits to performance bonuses could immediately reduce investment and hiring, exacerbate the concentration of talent at large companies, and deepen the dual structure of the labor market. If primary contractors’ labor and management agree to a system that allocates a fixed percentage of operating profit as performance bonuses, subcontractors and partner companies are expected to face even greater financial difficulties due to cost-cutting pressures.


Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

There is also growing controversy over whether it is legitimate for unions to use the right to strike to demand performance bonuses. On May 20, President Lee Jaemyung strongly criticized such demands at a cabinet meeting, stating, "The demand for fixed distribution of operating profit crosses the line of common sense."



Park Jisoon, a professor at Korea University Law School, commented, "It should be up to the company to decide whether profits are distributed to secure talent or invested in new businesses. If performance bonuses are fixed at 'N% of operating profit,' it will make it harder to prioritize business decisions flexibly." He added, "This could have a significantly negative impact on sustainable management."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing