[New York Diary] "Have You Tried Ceres Pizza?"... New York Pizza Evolves into Fine Dining
Premium Ingredients at L'industrie and MAMA's TOO!
Fine Dining Style at Ceres
New York's Income Gap Reflected in Pizza
Recently, a generational shift has been taking place in New York City's pizza market, with "Ceres," which debuted last year, standing at the center of this transformation. Ceres is a pizzeria opened by chefs who previously worked at "Eleven Madison Park," an icon of New York fine dining. In 2017, Eleven Madison Park was ranked No. 1 on the "World's 50 Best Restaurants" list and was also awarded the highest Michelin rating of three stars.
Traditionally, New York pizza was simple—prioritizing quick turnover, minimal toppings, and affordability. Well-known spots like Joe's Pizza and Lombardi's Pizza are prime examples. These places typically reheated pre-baked pizzas and sold them in large, thin slices. The image of pizza as New Yorkers’ soul food and a staple for workers was strong.
The Lindustry store in New York's West Village is always crowded with people. New York (USA) – Photo by Yoonjoo Hwang
View original imageAround 2017, the evolution of New York pizza began. Pizzerias known as the "second generation," such as L'industrie Pizzeria and MAMA's TOO!, started gaining attention. They set themselves apart with "premium ingredients." L'industrie's burrata and fig pizzas, featuring toppings never seen before, quickly became must-try destinations in New York. I remember being surprised by the long line outside L'industrie on my first visit. While I was initially skeptical, the taste was unmistakably different from traditional pizza.
The signature burrata pizza, for example, felt noticeably fresher than others. The umami-rich tomato sauce and burrata cheese combined in perfect harmony. The olive oil drizzled on top was not overpowering and instead enhanced the flavor of the thin crust. The fig pizza offered the quintessential "sweet and salty" taste that many Koreans enjoy and left quite an impression.
Thick "Mamas Two" pizza dough like focaccia bread. New York, USA – Photo by Yoonju Hwang
View original imageMAMA's TOO! reinterpreted Sicilian-style pizza, with a thick focaccia-like crust, and gained popularity on social media platforms like Instagram. Here, they boldly use hearty vodka cream sauce, basil pesto, cheese, or spicy honey as toppings. The signature vodka pizza, generously topped with tomato and cream sauce, may feel a bit heavy for some Koreans. On the other hand, the funghi (mushroom) pizza or the Norma (hot honey) pizza were flavors anyone could enjoy.
The 'Seris' Pizza is gaining attention recently in New York. New York, USA — Photo by Yoonjoo Hwang
View original imageCeres Pizza takes things even further, now being called a "third-generation" pizza. Every part of the process—flour blending, topping design, and only offering whole pies—differs from typical pizzerias. They follow the logic of fine-dining restaurants. Because of this, some have even described Ceres as elevating pizza to the level of haute cuisine.
For example, when making their dough, Ceres records the exact weight of each type of flour used. Beyond that, they meticulously document the indoor temperature, the weight of the sourdough starter, and even the temperature of the water used.
Co-founder Jacob Ceribnick told Bon Appetit in an interview, "We try to control every variable." The practice of recording flour weight, indoor temperature, and water temperature is akin to the precise operations found in fine dining.
The ordering method is also different. Ceres only accepts orders for whole pies—no slices are sold. This significantly increases the financial burden for diners. In effect, pizza has shifted from being "workers' food" to a "capitalists’ delicacy."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
However, the $1.99 pizza shops tucked away in New York’s backstreets remain busy. It's still easy to find workers grabbing a quick bite there. For them, spending dozens of times more money just to eat pizza would be incomprehensible. In this sense, the evolution of New York pizza may well be the clearest reflection of the city’s income polarization.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.