Court: "Over Half of English Abstract Duplicated"
"Misconduct Beyond Statute of Limitations Can Be Considered in Disciplinary Measures"

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

A professor at Seoul National University who was dismissed for plagiarism filed a lawsuit claiming the disciplinary action was unjust, but the court did not accept the claim.


According to the legal community on the 18th, the 11th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court (Presiding Judge Kim Junyoung) ruled against the plaintiff last March in a lawsuit filed by former Seoul National University Department of Korean Language and Literature Professor A against the Teacher Appeals Commission seeking the cancellation of the dismissal decision.


Professor A, who had served as a tenured professor at Seoul National University since 2012, came under suspicion of plagiarizing sentences and English abstracts in academic papers. The investigation by the Research Integrity Committee at Seoul National University found that, among the 12 papers authored by Professor A, 4 constituted research misconduct, and 7 constituted inappropriate research conduct, with the violations deemed to be of moderate to serious degree.


Accordingly, Seoul National University dismissed Professor A in October 2024. Professor A filed a lawsuit, arguing that “the Research Integrity Committee determined the degree of violation as moderate to serious in general terms without making individual assessments of each paper, and that considering papers that were already beyond the statute of limitations for disciplinary action constituted an abuse of discretion.”

Dismissal of Seoul National University Professor for Academic Plagiarism Justified... Court: "Higher Ethical Standards Required" View original image

However, the court did not accept this argument. In response to Professor A’s claim of procedural defect, the court stated, “There is no obligation for the Research Integrity Committee to determine the degree of violation for each paper individually,” and added, “As the committee presented specific grounds for the papers subject to disciplinary action and found them to constitute research misconduct, it cannot be considered that the committee failed in its duty.”


Regarding the extent of the plagiarism, the court noted, “The sentences in the papers are highly similar to those in the papers used for comparison and lack citation marks. In particular, more than half of the English abstract is duplicated,” and pointed out, “This constitutes serious research misconduct that is either intentional or constitutes a grave breach of a researcher’s duty of care.”



The court also ruled that the level of the disciplinary action was appropriate. The court explained, “University professors are required to have a higher level of ethical awareness and moral standards than ordinary professionals,” and “In light of the persistence and repetition of the research misconduct, intentionality is recognized and the case falls within the ‘dismissal to discharge’ range stipulated by disciplinary standards.” The court further ruled, “According to Supreme Court precedents, even acts that are already past the disciplinary statute of limitations may be taken into account as reference when determining the severity of the disciplinary measure.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing