Securities Firms Lead with Brokerage and IMA, Surpassing Banks in Profitability

“Growth Limited with Banks Alone”... Rising Sense of Crisis Among Financial Holding Companies

Expanding Risk in Securities Divisions to Strengthen Capital Market

Domestic securities firms are rapidly closing the performance gap with banks, leveraging the stock market boom and shaking up the landscape of the financial sector. While bank-centered financial holding companies have seen growth stagnate due to their limited, loan-driven profit structures, financial groups with securities companies as core affiliates are scaling up through explosive brokerage (commission trading) revenues resulting from the stock market rally, as well as capital expansion via Integrated Investment Accounts (IMA) sales. As a result, some financial holding companies are fiercely working to strengthen their non-banking competitiveness, for example by increasing the limit on risk-weighted assets (RWA) allocated to their securities subsidiaries.


Securities Firms with 1 Trillion Won Quarterly Net Profit Shake Up the Financial Sector... Nervous Financial Holding Companies Say "The Race for No. 1 Is Changing" View original image

According to the financial sector on May 13, Mirae Asset Securities posted a consolidated net profit of 1.019 trillion won in the first quarter of this year, becoming the first securities company in the industry to achieve "1 trillion won in quarterly net profit." This figure surpasses not only Woori Financial Group (which relies heavily on bank profits and posted 603.8 billion won) but also NH NongHyup Financial Group (868.8 billion won). As global investment banks (IBs) raise their KOSPI index targets up to "10,000 points," the strong performance of major domestic securities firms is expected to continue for some time. Consequently, there are even projections that this year, some securities firms may surpass commercial banks in annual profit.


This reversal trend was first detected last year. Korea Investment & Securities posted an annual net profit of 2.0135 trillion won, surpassing NH NongHyup Bank (1.814 trillion won), a core affiliate of one of the five largest financial groups. The net profit gap with Woori Bank (2.6066 trillion won) was also relatively small.


Just two years ago, the gap between the two sides was significant. As of 2024, Mirae Asset Securities and Korea Investment & Securities reported annual net profits of approximately 893.6 billion won and 1.1 trillion won, respectively. In contrast, Woori Bank's net profit during the same period stood at 3.0394 trillion won—more than double that of major securities firms—and NH NongHyup Bank posted 1.807 trillion won. Considering that the total net profit of Korea Financial Holdings (1.033 trillion won) at the time did not even reach the earnings of a single commercial bank, the change is striking.

Securities Firms with 1 Trillion Won Quarterly Net Profit Shake Up the Financial Sector... Nervous Financial Holding Companies Say "The Race for No. 1 Is Changing" View original image

Banks are fundamentally structured to rely on interest income. However, since the inauguration of the Lee Jaemyung administration, a continued tightening of lending regulations and a changing interest rate environment have clearly revealed the limits to growth. In contrast, securities-centered financial groups have found themselves in a more favorable growth environment due to skyrocketing brokerage profits, a "money move" (capital shift) into the stock market, and expectations of further expansion in IMAs and issued notes. In particular, the IMA—often called a "securities company version of a deposit"—is a significant driver. Korea Investment & Securities has already launched up to the fourth IMA product, with cumulative fundraising for the first three alone reaching 2.1 trillion won. A commercial bank official commented, "The introduction of the IMA has given securities firms wings. The ability to stably secure customer funds for use in large-scale investment and management poses the biggest threat."


This has resulted in a heightened sense of crisis among bank-centered financial holding companies. Yang Jonghee, Chairman of KB Financial, reportedly expressed his concerns over the rise of Mirae Asset Securities and Korea Investment & Securities during a recent executive meeting. As the financial market is being reorganized into a structure of securities holding companies (such as Korea Investment Holdings and Mirae Asset), conglomerate holding companies (Samsung and Hanwha), and financial holding companies (the big five), there is a growing recognition that the traditional bank-centered holding company model has its limitations. This suggests that the issue is not just a matter of competition among financial holding companies, but that there is a need to respond to the broader shift toward capital market-centered financial operations. A high-ranking official at KB Financial said, "We see the rapid expansion of AUM (assets under management) at Mirae Asset Securities and Korea Investment & Securities as the biggest threat factor."


However, it is not easy for securities subsidiaries of financial holding companies to adopt aggressive investment strategies like those of Mirae Asset Securities. This is because the holding company structure itself is at a disadvantage compared to securities-centric financial groups in terms of risk allocation. Dedicated securities firms such as Korea Investment & Securities and Mirae Asset can concentrate capital and risk in the securities business, but financial holding companies like Shinhan and KB must allocate their RWA limits across multiple affiliates—including banks, card companies, capital, and insurance. In other words, it is difficult to concentrate resources in a specific sector as dedicated securities firms do.


Nevertheless, signs of change are emerging. This reflects the growing awareness that, amid the expansion of the capital market and the push for more productive finance, group-level capital allocation strategies also need to evolve. KB Financial is now reviewing options to allocate more RWA—previously concentrated in the banking sector—to its securities segment. However, the company notes that due to significant volatility in variables such as exchange rates and asset growth rates, it has yet to set a concrete target.


Shinhan Financial Group is reportedly experiencing a similar shift. A senior official at Shinhan Financial Group said, "Recently, there is a growing internal consensus that the securities business should not be seen merely as a supplementary function to banking, but as a core pillar of the capital market. Accordingly, there are moves to gradually expand both the targets and risk allocation for the securities segment."


The environment in which financial holding companies must remain mindful of supervisory authorities is also a constraint on proactive management moves. Securities subsidiaries of financial holding companies, due to regulatory oversight, are compelled to be more cautious with high-risk investments, while holding companies with securities firms as their main affiliates are relatively free from regulatory and reputational burdens.



A high-ranking official at a financial holding company stated, "If a bank-centered financial holding company were to actively support a private equity fund such as MBK, provide funding for management rights disputes, or engage in high-risk restructuring finance, it could face social criticism and regulatory pressure from financial authorities questioning why a bank-based group with public responsibilities is behaving so aggressively."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing