Two Months of Oil Price Controls... The Exit Dilemma
Time to Consider the Endgame and a Soft Landing Strategy

[Reporter’s Notebook] As the Price Ceiling Drags On, It’s Time to Design an Exit Roadmap View original image

"They told us to sell at low prices, but now there is barely any fuel left to sell."


Mr. Kim (55), who operates a gas station in Seoul, expressed his difficulties in securing inventory as the petroleum price ceiling policy drags on. He explained that because refiners, under government price controls, are required to sell fuel cheaply, they have imposed quantity restrictions, leaving gas stations with virtually depleted stocks. The amount of fuel currently available is less than one-third of what it used to be. Kim said, "Refiners at least receive compensation for their losses, but gas stations are left to shoulder all the criticism for selling at high prices."


The fourth round of the petroleum price ceiling policy, which took effect on April 24, is set to expire on May 7. It marks the first time in 29 years since oil prices were liberalized in 1997 that the government has directly intervened in the petroleum market. The policy was intended to ease inflation and economic hardship for the public amid surging oil prices caused by the Middle East crisis.


The policy achieved clear results as a short-term measure. It helped stabilize prices by suppressing the rapid rise in oil costs. The average gasoline price, which had soared to 1,927 won per liter, dropped to 1,819 won after the first announcement. The long queues at gas stations also disappeared. However, a side effect emerged as artificially lowered prices failed to curb petroleum consumption.


The growing amount of loss compensation for refiners is also a burden. The compensation amount currently estimated by the refining industry exceeds 3 trillion won, which is about 70% of the government's total reserve fund of 4.2 trillion won. There is also a significant difference of opinion between the government and the oil industry regarding the basis for loss compensation. While the government insists on compensating based on production costs, the industry is demanding compensation based on product prices.


Policymakers are clearly aware of these concerns as well. Kim Jeonggwan, Minister of Trade, Industry and Energy, recently told reporters, "Personally, I do not see the price ceiling policy as an ideal solution," adding, "If the Middle East war ends or oil prices stabilize, we will end it as soon as possible."


Now, it is time to discuss a 'responsible exit' to restore the market to normal conditions. However, abruptly withdrawing the policy is not the answer either. If the price ceiling is lifted while oil prices remain high, a significant increase in suppressed petroleum product prices is inevitable. In Pakistan, for instance, gasoline and diesel prices were frozen at government-announced levels from February to May 2022, but after the policy ended, the price of gasoline soared by 66%, from 149.9 rupees per liter to 248.7 rupees.



Ultimately, what is needed is a 'soft-landing strategy.' More important than the power to suppress prices is the ability to return the market to its normal trajectory. The focus should now move beyond assessing the policy’s success or failure, and instead be on crafting an exit strategy that minimizes shock to the market.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing