Blue House Signals Reform of 'Cruel Finance'... Will the Interest Rate System Be Overturned?
Kim Yongbeom: "Credit Ratings Are an Invisible Badge of Rank"
Calls for a Complete Overhaul of the Current Credit Rating System
"Interest Rates Reflect Risk... Undermining Market Principles Will Have Side Effects"
Kim Yongbeom, the policy chief at the Blue House, has been openly criticizing the domestic credit rating system in the financial sector, signaling upcoming reforms in what he calls "cruel finance." By fundamentally questioning the financial structure that applies low interest rates to high-credit borrowers and high rates to low-credit borrowers, he has called for a major overhaul of the current credit rating framework. Both within and outside the financial sector, concerns are growing that such an approach could distort the interest rate system, which is based on market principles, going beyond the original purpose of expanding inclusive finance.
According to the financial sector on May 4, Kim recently posted a series of three articles titled "The Structure of Finance Series" on his personal social media account, highlighting the limitations of the current credit rating system.
Regarding the current structure, he criticized it as "an invisible badge of rank designed by finance," questioning, "Why does the person struggling the most bear the heaviest interest burden?" He further argued, "Credit ratings are strictly backward-looking and do not predict the future," emphasizing that "the outdated framework of credit assessment must be boldly expanded." Addressing commercial banks, he pointed out that they "remain trapped in the safe greenhouse of high-credit borrowers" and insisted, "Banks will only move if the rules of the game are changed to make growth difficult without filling certain segments." This aligns with President Lee Jaemyung's characterization of the structure, in which low-credit borrowers bear higher interest rates, as "cruel finance."
With the Blue House directly identifying the credit rating system and interest rate polarization as issues and demanding solutions from financial authorities and banks, a follow-up response from the Financial Services Commission (FSC) has become inevitable. Although the FSC previously announced a "Plan to Revitalize Mid-Interest Rate Loans" on April 27, Kim's recent remarks suggest that such policies alone are insufficient to meaningfully improve access for financially vulnerable groups.
There are significant concerns in the market that the push to overhaul the credit rating system could undermine the fundamental structure of interest rate determination. Credit assessment is fundamentally a system designed based on past financial histories, a practice not much different in other major countries. For example, in the United States and elsewhere, alternative credit assessments have been introduced to incorporate non-financial information such as telecommunications bills, utility payments, and rent. However, these measures are intended to incorporate "thin filers"—those with limited financial history—into the mainstream financial system.
A university professor, speaking on condition of anonymity, noted, "Alternative credit assessments in the U.S. aim to bring consumers with no financial history into the mainstream financial system, not to expand lending to low-credit borrowers." He added, "Korea has also been working to introduce alternative credit assessments that reflect non-financial data and to advance the credit rating system, which is positive. However, directly linking this to expanding loans to low-credit borrowers or lowering interest rates is not appropriate."
Criticism is also being raised that treating interest rates as a form of "welfare" could clash with market principles. Interest rates are a "price" that reflect a borrower's ability to repay and the risk of default; the lower the risk, the lower the rate, and the higher the risk, the higher the rate—this is a basic principle of finance. Banks, in particular, explain that once a certain credit threshold is crossed, default rates increase sharply, making interest rate gaps structurally inevitable. According to the FSC, as of August last year, the average interest rates on unsecured loans by credit rating across all sectors were 4.9% to 5% for those in the 10th to 6th deciles (high-credit borrowers), 5.4% for the 5th decile (mid-credit borrowers), 10.7% for the 3rd decile (mid-credit borrowers), and as high as 13.9% for the 1st decile (low-credit borrowers). Attempts to unilaterally eliminate this "interest rate fault line" could result in a "credit cliff," where mid-credit borrowers are unable to obtain loans from banks at all.
An official in the financial sector commented, "If you want to lower the rates for mid- and low-credit borrowers, banks must either bear losses or pass on the costs by raising rates for high-credit borrowers. Otherwise, banks will reduce lending to mid-credit borrowers, which could push them into the secondary financial sector, causing negative side effects."
Currently, banks are already playing a role in supporting mid-credit borrowers by offering policy financial products for low-income consumers, such as Sae-Hyup Hope Loans and Saitdol Loans.
Due to the government's emphasis on inclusive finance, there are already signs of interest rate distortions. According to disclosures by the Korea Federation of Banks, the average interest rate on general unsecured loans for ultra-high-credit borrowers (credit scores above 950) at the five major commercial banks rose by 0.03 percentage points from 4.47% in December last year to 4.5% in March this year, while rates for mid-credit borrowers (credit scores in the 800s) fell by 0.1 percentage points from 5.752% to 5.659% during the same period.
There is also criticism regarding the contradiction between stricter total household loan regulations, which restrict lending to highly creditworthy borrowers, and policies demanding expanded lending to mid- and low-credit borrowers. Since the launch of the current administration, the gap between the financial principle of "borrow only as much as you can repay" and policy direction has grown excessively wide.
While the financial sector agrees with the goal of alleviating the financial exclusion of mid- and low-credit borrowers and expanding inclusive finance, it emphasizes that this should be achieved through methods such as expanded government guarantees or increased contributions from financial companies, rather than undermining market principles.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An official in the financial sector stated, "Coming from a policy leader with extensive experience in the market as an economic and financial bureaucrat, the remarks seem to lack sufficient consideration of market principles. It is preferable to address the expansion of inclusive finance and the issues of the credit rating and interest rate systems separately."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.