Court Sides with Credit Card Company

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

A court has ruled that insurance agency commissions received by credit card companies from insurance firms do not constitute “financial or insurance business income” subject to education tax.


According to the legal community on May 3, the 8th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court (Presiding Judge Yang Sunjoo) ruled in favor of Hyundai Card this past February in its lawsuit against the Yeongdeungpo Tax Office chief, seeking to overturn the refusal to reassess its education tax.


The case began in 2018, when Hyundai Card requested a refund of education tax already paid, arguing that commissions earned from insurance agency work were not subject to education tax. Previously, Hyundai Card had filed a similar lawsuit over education tax for fiscal years 2013 to 2017 and won a Supreme Court ruling in its favor in 2021.


However, as the earlier ruling did not apply to education tax for fiscal year 2018, the tax office once again rejected Hyundai Card’s request for reassessment. Hyundai Card subsequently filed another administrative lawsuit. The disputed amount relating to insurance agency commissions was approximately 132.22 million won out of the total reassessment refusal amount of about 3.9 billion won.


The court found the tax authority’s refusal to reassess to be unlawful and sided with the card company. The court stated, “Under the Specialized Credit Finance Business Act, insurance agency work is considered an ‘ancillary business’ for card companies, not their principal business,” and added, “It is reasonable to conclude that income from such work should not be included in taxable income under the Education Tax Act.”



The court further noted, “The obligation to pay education tax is determined not by the taxpayer’s legal status, but by the type of business through which the income is generated,” emphasizing, “Insurance agency commissions cannot be regarded as income arising from a card company’s principal or incidental business.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing