Ownership of the Deceased Is Extinguished,
Possession Interpreted to Belong to Responding Police Officers

The suspect who took a gold necklace from a corpse argued that his actions did not constitute theft, but the court ultimately ruled that it was theft.


The photo is not directly related to the content of the article. Pixabay

The photo is not directly related to the content of the article. Pixabay

View original image

According to the Incheon District Court on May 3, forensic examiner A (34), affiliated with the Scientific Investigation Unit of the Incheon Metropolitan Police Agency, discovered a 30-don gold necklace worth approximately 20 million won worn by deceased male B, in his 50s, at the scene of an unattended death in a villa in Namdong-gu on August 20 last year. A then removed the necklace and hid it in his sneaker before leaving the villa.


However, after the gold necklace was identified in the initial crime scene photo taken by police, an internal investigation was launched targeting five people who had responded to the scene: two detectives, one forensic examiner, and two scientific investigation unit employees. Under police questioning, A eventually confessed to the crime. During the trial, A admitted to taking the necklace but claimed that it fell under the category of ‘misappropriation of lost property’ rather than theft, arguing that the necklace did not belong to anyone at the time. He asserted that since B was already deceased, the necklace was ownerless. Nevertheless, prosecutors charged A with theft.


Under criminal law, theft can be punished by up to six years in prison or a fine of up to 10 million won. However, misappropriation of lost property carries a lighter sentence: up to one year in prison or a fine of up to 3 million won.


Judge Kim Kiho of the Incheon District Court Criminal Division 9, who presided over the case, found it difficult to recognize that either the deceased B or B’s heirs still maintained possession of the necklace at the time A took it. The judge further determined that, as A had no involvement in B’s death and there was no temporal proximity between the death and the act, it was reasonable by social standards to deem that the deceased’s possession of the necklace had ceased.


Nevertheless, the court ultimately applied the crime of theft to A. This was because the location where the gold necklace was found was a crime scene under strict police control and management. According to a Supreme Court precedent, “if an item is left in a place under someone else’s management, the manager’s possession is recognized, and if a third party takes it without permission,” it constitutes theft. The court thus judged that, since the responding officers controlled and managed B’s residence as an unattended death scene and restricted entry as part of their initial response, they were in possession of the items at the scene as managers. The court sentenced A to a fine of 10 million won.


Judge Kim pointed out, “The defendant, as a government official tasked with forensic duties in cases of unattended death, bears a high standard of professional ethics, yet is highly blameworthy for stealing the deceased’s belongings.” While a forensic examiner is not a police officer, they are a civil servant affiliated with the Scientific Investigation Unit of the city or provincial police agency, dispatched to scenes of unexplained deaths to investigate the cause of death.



However, the judge also stated, “If a sentence of imprisonment or higher were finalized, it would constitute grounds for mandatory dismissal, which would be somewhat harsh for the defendant,” adding, “In sentencing, the court took into account the fact that the stolen property was returned to the bereaved family and that an amicable settlement was reached.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing