"Possible That Pilot Shut Down the Wrong Engine"


Similar to Controversial Initial Findings by Accident Investigation Board

The New York Times (NYT), a major U.S. daily, reported that pilot error appears to have worsened the situation in its analysis of the cause of the Jeju Air passenger plane disaster at Muan International Airport on December 29, 2024.


On the 1st (local time), the NYT investigative reporting team published an article titled "The Final Moments of Jeju Air Flight 2216: What Happens When Pilots Act Too Quickly in a Crisis," arguing that "the pilots responded too quickly, leading them into a predicament that could have been avoided, which may have exacerbated the situation."

Members of the Bereaved Families Association of the Muan Airport Jeju Air Passenger Plane Disaster held a press conference denouncing the initial response failure and state responsibility in front of the Sarangchae of the Blue House in Seoul on the 9th of last month. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Members of the Bereaved Families Association of the Muan Airport Jeju Air Passenger Plane Disaster held a press conference denouncing the initial response failure and state responsibility in front of the Sarangchae of the Blue House in Seoul on the 9th of last month. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The NYT cited black box records showing that the pilots shut down the engines after a bird strike as evidence. The report stated that the left engine lever was moved to the fuel cutoff position and the left engine's fire switch was pulled, noting, "This may have been the wrong engine," and calling it "a major mistake by the pilots."

It further explained, "Although both engines were damaged, video footage taken on the ground captured the right engine displaying more serious problems," adding, "The complete loss of power immediately after the left fire switch was pulled suggests that the right engine was the greater issue."


This is similar to the initial findings released last July by the Aviation and Railway Accident Investigation Board (ARAIB) to the bereaved families. At the time, the ARAIB shared at a briefing for the families that "there is evidence the pilot shut down the left engine, not the right engine, which had sustained greater damage from the bird strike," sparking controversy. The bereaved families fiercely protested, claiming that the ARAIB was shifting blame onto the pilot while downplaying the government's responsibility for constructing the 'concrete embankment.'


However, the NYT also identified the concrete embankment as a decisive factor in the disaster, in addition to the pilots' actions. Chesley Sullenberger, the former airline captain renowned for the "Miracle on the Hudson," told the NYT, "If it hadn’t been for that concrete barrier, they probably would have survived." The report also emphasized that the plane's belly landing in the middle of the runway without deploying its landing gear was "an astonishing feat in many respects."



The NYT had previously pointed out in an investigative report last August that "the solid wall at the end of the runway appears to have increased the scale of the disaster, as compared to if there had been no wall." It further noted, "The South Korean government has missed opportunities to address the problem of the concrete embankment, despite being aware of it."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing