Department Stores and Hypermarkets Show Stark Contrast in Sales Growth

Reflected in Stock Prices... E-Mart’s Upturn Remains Modest

Asset Gains and Record Bonuses Accelerate Polarization in Consumption

Flexing at Department Stores, Pinching Pennies at Marts... Retail Stocks Mirror K-Shaped Polarization [Weekend Money] View original image

The gap within the domestic retail industry is becoming increasingly pronounced. Even within the same offline retail channels, department stores are benefiting from a recovery in consumer spending, while large discount stores are struggling to find signs of a rebound.


According to the Korea Exchange on May 2, department store stocks such as Shinsegae and Hyundai Department Store have shown relatively strong performance recently, with Lotte Shopping also rising significantly. However, analysts suggest that both expectations for department stores and hopes for regulatory easing are intertwined in these trends. In contrast, despite some signs of a rebound, many believe it is still too early to conclude that E-Mart's business environment has fully recovered. In fact, since the beginning of this month, shares of Hyundai Department Store and Shinsegae have risen by about 40% and 38%, respectively, while Lotte Shopping has climbed nearly 30%. On the other hand, E-Mart's increase was limited to around 13%.


This divergence is also evident in their business results. According to IBK Investment & Securities, referencing data from the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, major retailers' sales in March rose 5.6% year-on-year. Online sales increased by 8.1%, and offline sales grew by 1.9%, indicating an overall growth trend. On the surface, both online and offline channels appear to be performing well, but a closer look reveals a stark difference by channel.


In the offline segment, department stores stood out the most. In March, department store sales grew by 14.7% year-on-year, driving the overall growth. Even after accounting for temporary factors such as the timing of holidays, sales recovered across the board, including apparel, fashion, accessories, as well as home appliances and furniture. While luxury goods were the main driver of growth until last year, there is now a sense that the consumer base has broadened somewhat.


This change is believed to be driven by the rise in asset values. Since the second half of last year, financial asset values have increased, leading to higher asset income in addition to earned income, and large bonuses paid by some companies may also have boosted consumption capacity. This structure is expected to persist for some time. Nam Seonghyun, a researcher at IBK Investment & Securities, explained, "The consumption capacity of lower-income groups is shrinking, while the consumption capacity of higher-income groups, who can leverage their assets to increase income, is expanding. As a result, growth in offline channels led by department stores is likely to continue for the time being."

Flexing at Department Stores, Pinching Pennies at Marts... Retail Stocks Mirror K-Shaped Polarization [Weekend Money] View original image

On the other hand, the slump of large discount stores is deepening more than expected. In March, sales at large discount stores fell by 15.2% year-on-year. While this may reflect the impact of store closures by some major operators, analysts point out that the resulting demand is not shifting to competitors, but rather the overall market demand is weakening. Particularly noteworthy is the fact that large discount stores, which mainly handle essential consumer goods, are faltering. Researcher Nam commented, "Contrary to the general perception that demand for essential consumer goods is less sensitive to economic cycles, the results are different. The growth of luxury goods channels remains solid, while essential consumer goods are declining, entrenching a classic K-shaped polarization."



The online channel is showing relatively stable growth. In March, online sales increased by 8.1%. This is seen as a result of consumers increasingly prioritizing both price competitiveness and convenience when purchasing essential goods. Households with reduced consumption capacity are paying closer attention to price and efficiency, while even those with greater spending power are exhibiting a rational consumption pattern in essential goods. Researcher Nam diagnosed, "Rather than simply a shift from offline to online demand, these results reflect changes in consumption patterns caused by K-shaped polarization."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing