Report Card on Personal Data Protection in Public Institutions

In 2025, a year marked by a series of hacking incidents at private companies such as the three major telecom operators, Coupang, and Lotte Card, the privacy protection performance of public institutions also received failing marks. According to the results of the "2025 Public Institution Personal Information Protection Level Assessment" announced by the Personal Information Protection Commission, only 54 out of 1,442 institutions surveyed (6.6%) received the highest grade (Grade S), an increase of nine from the previous year. Taken on its own, this figure could be interpreted as progress. However, it is notable that the number of institutions earning Grade A plummeted by as many as 60.


Pixabay

Pixabay

View original image

The Personal Information Protection Commission explained that the overall "efforts to ensure safety measures" score for public institutions in this assessment was only 2.26 out of 5, indicating a low level. The main reasons cited were the omission of decision-making procedures such as obtaining approval from the head of the institution when establishing internal management plans, and the prevalence of perfunctory implementation checks.


It is particularly noteworthy that the Ministry of Science and ICT, which is responsible for technology and user protection, and the Broadcasting and Media Communications Commission, received grades of B and C, respectively. Both dropped by one grade compared to the previous year. This means these agencies, which emphasize guidelines for private companies, failed to properly adhere to those standards themselves. Considering the Ministry of Science and ICT's symbolic role as the leading agency for national information security policy and security technology R&D, this is a disappointing outcome. The fact that its own protection level did not reach the upper grades makes it difficult to avoid criticism for "failing to set an example." The same applies to the Broadcasting and Media Communications Commission. As an institution responsible for protecting the rights of telecommunications service users and regulating personal information leak incidents, receiving a Grade C undermines the credibility of its policies.


The failing marks received by basic local governments are a chronic issue. The National Fire Agency, the Korea Aerospace Administration (KASA), certain basic local governments, and other public institutions received the lowest grades, with basic local governments scoring an average of 73.2 points—down from 74.8 points a year earlier. The gap in protection capabilities is pronounced, with a 14.3-point difference compared to public enterprises and quasi-governmental agencies, which averaged 87.5 points. Despite handling vast amounts of personal data closely related to citizens' daily lives, these institutions have failed to strengthen their management systems due to budget and manpower shortages.


The development of artificial intelligence (AI) technology is increasing the threat of hacking. Attacks are becoming more sophisticated and faster, reaching a level that is already difficult for humans to defend against, and now even targeting the AI models themselves. Security has moved beyond merely "establishing firewalls" to an era where "AI must be countered with AI." Reflecting this trend, this year's nationwide information security budget was set at 401.2 billion won, an increase of about 7.7% compared to the previous year's 372.4 billion won. This amount is earmarked to raise security levels across the country and support the growth of private industry. While these efforts are important, it is essential that each public institution strives to set an example in security to lend strength to these policies.



The Personal Information Protection Commission stated that it will link the results of this assessment to government work evaluations and conduct improvement recommendations and follow-up checks for underperforming institutions. In addition, it plans to raise the protection level of public institutions through tailored consulting. Beyond the annual guidance efforts, it is necessary to consider practical measures such as securing specialized personnel and strengthening penalties to enhance accountability.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing