Record-High Volatility and Soaring Market

Excessive Reliance on Semiconductors and Government Intervention

Urgent Need to Foster a Developed-Market Corporate Environment

Introduction of a Differentiated Voting Rights System Needed Pro

[Insight & Opinion] Is Our Stock Market on the Right Track? View original image

Looking back over the past year, the volatility of the KOSPI index has reached an all-time high. On May 11, the index surged past the 7,800 mark, reaching a record high of 7,876—approximately 3.44 times greater than its lowest point of 2,284 recorded in April last year. Compared to past crises, such as the 2.2-fold increase during the 2008 financial crisis or the 1.5-fold increase during the COVID-19 period in 2020, this level of volatility is being interpreted by some not as a positive sign, but rather as a 'crisis.'


During the 2008 financial crisis, the market collapsed due to 'panic selling' triggered by fears of a breakdown in the financial system. After 2009, as central banks around the world responded simultaneously to the global economic crisis, the market recovered a significant portion of its losses within a year. By contrast, while the market experienced a comparable downturn in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic, the recovery was much swifter, resulting in a rapid bull market. The index plummeted by 35% from 2,200 to 1,400, but rebounded quickly and even broke through the 3,300 mark within a year. This artificially driven bull market can be attributed to unlimited quantitative easing worldwide, aggressive policy mobilization by various governments, and the emergence of beneficiary industries such as semiconductors and IT.


Today's surging market is not only remarkable in scale but also differs from previous episodes in that the extreme volatility has been sustained. The market environment is also distinct: rather than being driven by a single shock, there are simultaneous factors pulling in both directions. On the upside, there is anticipation of interest rate cuts in the United States, improvements in the semiconductor industry, growing demand for artificial intelligence (AI), and large-scale net buying by foreign investors. At the same time, there are downward pressures, including delays in U.S. interest rate cuts, a slowdown in the Chinese economy, sharp fluctuations in exchange rates, concerns about the semiconductor industry peaking, and ongoing conflicts such as the wars in the Middle East and between Russia and Ukraine.


Among these, what is particularly concerning is that the market is not performance-driven but rather relies on government intervention. The current administration's policies are fundamentally aimed at resolving the 'Korea discount' and are based on the judgment that it is better for individuals' assets to flow into the capital market than to remain tied up in real estate. While the degree of intervention varies, direct measures such as short-selling bans, tax incentives, and financial market stabilization are not overly aggressive. However, indirect intervention is pronounced, with policies such as the reassessment of companies with low price-to-book ratios (PBR) and the management of national pension funds in ways that defend the downside and amplify upward effects. Since foreigners and government policies are leading the market, its autonomy appears diminished. The market's heavy reliance on the semiconductor industry is another frequent point of criticism.


Is this truly the right direction? The U.S. stock market, as a developed market, is also affected by government policy. However, the key difference lies in the fact that U.S. companies fundamentally lead and grow the market through their own performance, within a well-established environment and system. In the United States, innovative companies emerge continuously in sectors such as energy, transportation, retail, biotech, IT, and AI. The government does not overtly implement policies aimed solely at boosting market indices.


The primary objective of the stock market is not for participants to profit through 'money games,' but for companies to secure funding to expand and grow their businesses. In this light, Korean companies should be required to maintain a certain level of shareholding sufficient to defend their management control even as they raise capital through listings. Government intervention should be focused on institutional support, such as introducing a 'differentiated voting rights system.' It is also worth noting that the high level of stock ownership among the U.S. middle class is not because the government encouraged individuals to invest in stocks, but because companies distributed shares or options to participants as performance incentives. Ultimately, the true path to developing the stock market lies in allowing companies to work passionately and distribute capital autonomously.



Kim Hongjin, CEO of Work Innovation Lab


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing