"Yellow Envelope Act Aims to Protect Indirectly Employed Workers"

On April 13, Sugeun Park, Chairperson of the Central Labor Relations Commission, addressed the first month since the implementation of the "Yellow Envelope Act" (Amendments to Articles 2 and 3 of the Labor Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act), emphasizing, "Recognition of substantial control does not mean wage increases or direct employment. Rather, it is a procedural concept that grants both the principal contractor and the subcontractor unions the status to sit at the negotiation table and engage in dialogue." He drew a clear line against the tendency to interpret the law as excessively expanding substantive rights.


During a press conference held that morning at the Government Complex Sejong, Chairperson Park stated, "When substantial control is recognized through the Yellow Envelope Act, it is often interpreted as leading to higher wages or direct employment, but this is not the case." He added, "This law is intended to change the principal contractor's existing stance of 'having no obligation to engage in dialogue due to the absence of a contractual relationship.'"

Park Sugun, Chairman of the Central Labor Relations Commission, is entering the meeting room to attend the 'Labor-Management Relations System and Practice Improvement Committee General Meeting' held at the Economic, Social and Labor Council in Jongno-gu, Seoul, back in 2019 when he was chairman of the Labor-Management Relations Committee. Photo by Kang Jinhyung aymsdream@

Park Sugun, Chairman of the Central Labor Relations Commission, is entering the meeting room to attend the 'Labor-Management Relations System and Practice Improvement Committee General Meeting' held at the Economic, Social and Labor Council in Jongno-gu, Seoul, back in 2019 when he was chairman of the Labor-Management Relations Committee. Photo by Kang Jinhyung aymsdream@

View original image

Expansion of Principal Employer Recognition... "Wages and Direct Employment Are Separate Issues"

Chairperson Park explained, "The primary significance of the Labor Relations Commission's determination is in recognizing procedural standing," adding, "The key is to have the principal contractor participate in negotiations and engage in dialogue with the subcontractor union." He continued, "The second aspect concerns the topics for bargaining, where various issues such as industrial safety, working conditions, indirect improvements to wages, and demands for direct employment may be discussed. However, this does not mean there is an obligation to accept these demands."


He further stated that, in actual cases, the possibility of recognizing employer status is relatively high in the area of industrial safety, while there is still no precedent for recognizing demands for wage increases or direct employment. Park said, "Wage-related issues can be discussed during negotiations, but there is no legal obligation for the principal contractor to accept them," and added, "The Ministry of Employment and Labor's guidelines also maintain that it is difficult to recognize such obligations from a legal perspective."


The number of cases submitted to the Labor Relations Commission has been rapidly increasing. Park noted, "Since the Act went into effect on March 10, there has been a significant increase in demands for negotiations and requests to separate bargaining units directed at principal contractors. In particular, there is a strong possibility that applications for corrective action will surge if employers fail to publicize the fact that bargaining demands have been made."


Regarding recent cases with conflicting rulings, he stressed the principle of "case-by-case judgment." For instance, in the POSCO case, a request for separate bargaining units was approved, while in the Coupang case, it was dismissed. He explained, "Outcomes may differ depending on the degree of conflict between unions and the maturity of the topics being discussed. Whether bargaining should be held jointly or separately must be determined based on each individual case." In response to criticisms that such variation causes "confusion," he countered, "Such an interpretation does not align with the intent of resolving disputes."


On the possibility of future labor disputes, Park said, "The main topic around which negotiations are conducted will become the key issue. If only some of the demands are recognized as falling under employer status, the legitimacy of industrial action will be judged by the courts according to which issue is considered the 'main topic.'"

Park Sugeun, Chairperson of the Central Labor Relations Commission, emphasized the on-site implementation of the revised bill ahead of the enforcement of the "Yellow Envelope Act" (Amendments to Articles 2 and 3 of the Labor Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act) during the "Ministry of Employment and Labor and Central Labor Relations Commission Joint Workshop" held on the 4th at the Sejong Convention Center. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Park Sugeun, Chairperson of the Central Labor Relations Commission, emphasized the on-site implementation of the revised bill ahead of the enforcement of the "Yellow Envelope Act" (Amendments to Articles 2 and 3 of the Labor Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act) during the "Ministry of Employment and Labor and Central Labor Relations Commission Joint Workshop" held on the 4th at the Sejong Convention Center. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

"Yellow Envelope Act Aims to Protect Indirectly Employed Workers"

Chairperson Park repeatedly highlighted that the core policy intent of the new law is to "protect indirectly employed workers." He said, "Indirectly employed workers, estimated to number over 1 million, are among the most vulnerable groups in the labor market. The key is to change the structure that, until now, has prevented them from even engaging in dialogue with the principal contractor due to the lack of a contractual relationship."


However, regarding concerns from the business community, he remarked, "Fears that all demands will be accepted during negotiations are excessive. The Labor Relations Commission will not make unilateral decisions but will recognize what should be recognized and reject what should be rejected."


On the application to the public sector, Park stated, "Because the business structure is more complex and interests are more diverse, it will take more time than in the private sector. As in the case of the National Tax Service call center, gradual adoption will occur through individual case assessments."



Chairperson Park reiterated, "This law does not mandate wage increases or direct employment. Rather, it is a mechanism to ensure that principal and subcontractor workers can at least have a dialogue. Please do not misunderstand the intent of the law."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing