Disagreement Over Highly Enriched Uranium
United States and Iran Confirm Differences Without Compromise

World journalists gather at the press center established in Islamabad, Pakistan. Press Center. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

World journalists gather at the press center established in Islamabad, Pakistan. Press Center. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The primary reason for the failure of the first face-to-face negotiations between the United States and Iran is the difference in their positions regarding Iran's nuclear program. The United States has demanded that Iran transfer its enriched uranium and dismantle its entire nuclear capability, while Iran has maintained its stance of not giving up its right to enrich uranium.


According to reports from the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) and others on April 12 (local time), the biggest obstacle in the recent negotiations between the United States and Iran was their disagreement over Iran's nuclear program.


Vice President JD Vance stated after the breakdown of the talks, "The simple fact is that we must be assured that Iran is not pursuing nuclear weapons and is firmly committed to not seeking the means to rapidly acquire one," he said.


In response, the Iranian side attributed the collapse of the discussions to what it called the United States’ "maximalist demands" and its uncompromising attitude.


The United States conducted two military operations against Iran last year in June and again this February, both aimed at eliminating Iran's nuclear capabilities. During the airstrikes in June, the United States used Tomahawk missiles to destroy nuclear facilities in Fordow, Natanz, and Isfahan. Isfahan is an area identified by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) as a site where uranium enriched to 20-60% is stored.


In the Iran war that began on February 28 this year, the United States focused on striking Iran's stockpiles of missiles and launchers along with other conventional military assets. The intent was to reduce the potential costs (damage) of future attacks on Iran's nuclear program. Over the past five weeks of airstrikes, research facilities used for nuclear weapons development were destroyed, and facilities for producing "yellowcake," the raw material for enriched uranium, also suffered damage.


Despite the large-scale airstrikes by the United States and Israel, Iran still appears to possess most of the resources needed for nuclear weapons production, including centrifuges, according to the WSJ.


The greatest uncertainty is how much the recent major attacks during the Iran war have actually damaged Iran's "nuclear warhead manufacturing capability." David Albright, president of the Institute for Science and International Security (ISIS) and a former nuclear inspector, assessed that "the damage Israel inflicted on Iran’s nuclear weapons capabilities could be significant, but the specific extent is still unclear."


What the United States is paying particular attention to is Iran’s stockpile of about 1,000 pounds (approximately 450 kg) of enriched uranium. It is currently estimated that half of this enriched uranium is buried in storage inside underground tunnels at the Isfahan nuclear facility. Previously, President Donald Trump considered deploying ground troops to seize Iran's stockpile of enriched uranium during the Iran war, but ultimately abandoned the plan due to its high risk.



Eric Brewer, a former White House official who managed Iran affairs in the first Trump administration, said, "Iran will not give this up easily," and analyzed, "The price it will demand in exchange for handing over enriched uranium will likely be even higher than what was asked in the negotiations last February."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing