Vatican's Moral Authority Clashes with Trump's Military Pressure

U.S. Defense Department Accused of Pressuring Apostolic Nuncio for Support

Thanksgiving Mass for the Election of Pope Leo XIV held last year at Myeongdong Cathedral. Photo by Yonhap News

Thanksgiving Mass for the Election of Pope Leo XIV held last year at Myeongdong Cathedral. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

The conflict between Pope Leo XIV and U.S. President Donald Trump over the Iran war is intensifying.


On April 12 (local time), according to Axios and other sources, the rift between the pope and President Trump over the Iran war is reaching an irreparable point.


After reciting the Angelus prayer at St. Peter's Square that day, the pope declared, "Humanitarian principles entail a moral obligation to protect civilians from the devastating effects of war."


The pope further emphasized, "Idolatry of self and money has gone far enough," and declared, "Enough with shows of force and war." He continued, "We must sit at a table of dialogue and mediation, not at a table where rearmament is planned."


In recent days, through messages released during Mass, the pope has been indirectly urging an end to the war between the United States, Israel, and Iran. At a special prayer meeting held the previous evening at St. Peter's Basilica, he criticized, "Delusions of omnipotence are fueling this war." He added, "Enough with idolatry of self and money! Enough with displays of power! Enough with war!"


On April 10, the pope also strongly criticized on social media, stating, "God does not bless any war," and, "If you are a disciple of Christ, the King of Peace, you stood with those who wielded swords in the past, and today, you do not stand with those who drop bombs."


Catholic dioceses in the United States are also supporting the pope's position. Cardinal Blase Cupich of the Chicago Archdiocese criticized, "Treating war, which involves real death and suffering, as if it were a video game is a nauseating act." Cardinal Robert McElroy of the Washington Archdiocese also pointed out that this war does not meet the Catholic doctrine's criteria for a 'just war.'


Axios reported that this reflects the voices of American Catholic leaders, who are generally more conservative than the Vatican, raising moral concerns such as civilian casualties and lack of legitimacy.


This conflict is also linked to the controversy surrounding a meeting in January between the U.S. Department of Defense and Cardinal Christophe Pierre, who was then the Apostolic Nuncio to the United States. At that time, Pentagon officials are said to have threatened Cardinal Christophe Pierre, urging the Vatican to support U.S. military tactics.



Andrew Chesnut, a professor at Virginia Commonwealth University, assessed that "Catholic resistance will exert significant moral pressure on the Trump Administration."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing