Government to Introduce Average Quantity Standard
to Prevent Manufacturer Loopholes

One out of every four standardized quantity-labeled products distributed in the market was found to contain less than the indicated amount.


Large Mart. Photo is not directly related to the article content. The Asia Business Daily DB

Large Mart. Photo is not directly related to the article content. The Asia Business Daily DB

View original image

On April 12, the National Institute of Technology and Standards under the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy announced that it conducted a sample survey of 1,002 quantity-labeled products, checking three samples for each product, to determine whether the actual content met the indicated quantity. The results showed that 25% of the products tested contained less than the stated amount, based on the average content by product.


This has led to interpretations that some manufacturers are exploiting the system by filling products with less content within the legal margin of error. Since current law makes it difficult to penalize as long as individual products are within the allowable error range, there are criticisms that manufacturers are engaging in a kind of "capacity diet" by setting the overall production line to package slightly less than the indicated quantity.


Beverages and alcoholic drinks were the most problematic category, with 44.8% of items averaging less content than indicated. This was followed by beans at 36.8%, milk at 32.4%, and soy sauce and vinegar at 31.0%. As these cases of underfilling are occurring frequently in essential daily necessities, consumers are likely to feel an even greater burden from rising prices.


To prevent such loopholes by certain manufacturers, the government is pursuing a legislative amendment that includes the introduction of an "average quantity standard." The amendment requires not only compliance with the margin of error but also that the average content of all products produced must meet or exceed the stated amount. The intent is to eliminate the practice of routinely underfilling products, even within the permissible tolerance range.


This survey was conducted on four types of products closely related to everyday life, with items purchased directly from large-scale supermarkets, local marts, and online malls. The target categories included: basic necessities such as rice, instant noodles, and milk; consumer-related items such as dairy products, beverages, and convenience foods; high-priced items relative to volume such as seasonings, alcoholic drinks, and organic foods; and items that are difficult to manage in terms of quantity, such as frozen seafood.


Additionally, in response to criticism that the annual survey sample size of about 1,000 is inadequate compared to the approximately KRW 400 trillion standardized product market, the government plans to significantly expand the scale of product surveys to over 10,000 items annually, referencing overseas examples—28,000 in China, 60,000 in Germany, and 160,000 in Japan. The National Institute of Technology and Standards also plans to strengthen public disclosure of companies found in violation and consider harsher penalties for habitual offenders, thereby building a more robust post-management system.


Meanwhile, quantity-labeled products refer to items such as toilet paper, snacks, and milk, where the packaging displays length, mass, or volume (e.g., "2m," "500g," "1.5L").



Products that exceeded the legal margin of error accounted for 2.8%, indicating that legal standards are generally being met. However, the violation rates were higher for certain categories: frozen seafood (fish and shellfish) at 9%, seaweed at 7.7%, soy sauce and vinegar at 7.1%, and sanitary and household goods at 5.7%.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing