[Why&Next]"Growth Achieved, but Nothing Left"...The Insurance Dilemma After IFRS 17
Channel Structure Transformation Driven by CSM Competition
Rising Costs, Shrinking Margins... Eroding Insurer Profits
The Dark Side of Fierce Competition: Solvency Risks on the Rise
As corporate insurance agencies (GA), which prioritize insurance planners, continue scaling up, the influence of distribution channels in the insurance market is expanding. However, a paradoxical structure has emerged in which intensified profitability competition following the introduction of the new accounting standard (IFRS 17) is actually fueling cost increases. Insurers have restructured their sales strategies to increase the Contractual Service Margin (CSM), but in the process, rising commissions and business expenses are eroding profits, resulting in an entrenched structure where "selling does not necessarily generate profits."
GA Scaling Up Driven by CSM Competition
According to the insurance industry on April 11, the insurance solicitation market is rapidly restructuring around corporate insurance agencies. Large GAs with annual sales exceeding 1 trillion won—such as Inka Financial Service, GA Korea, and Hanwha Life Financial Service—are emerging in succession, and the number of insurance planners is quickly increasing, solidifying the GA channel as a core pillar within the insurance industry. The Korea Insurance GA Association stated, "As the number of insurance planners increased last year, the industry saw a trend of workforce concentration and organizational expansion. In addition, both life and non-life insurance have experienced a significant rise in new contract volumes, contract amounts, and commission income, which continues to strengthen the market influence of the GA channel."
The starting point for this trend is the introduction of IFRS 17. In the past, insurers’ performance was mainly evaluated based on external indicators such as the size of insurance premiums, but after IFRS 17, CSM—which reflects future profits—has become the key indicator. As a result, insurers have shifted their sales strategies to focus on protection-type insurance products with higher CSM contributions. As the structure of core products has become more complex, the importance of explanation and ongoing management has increased, leading to greater reliance on face-to-face channels. Ultimately, IFRS 17 has transformed not only product structures but also channel strategies, thereby increasing the influence of GAs.
'Commission Competition' Leads to Declining Profitability
As channel competition intensifies, the cost structure is also changing rapidly. Due to insurers increasing upfront commissions to secure new contracts, the total recruitment commissions have more than tripled, rising from approximately 10 trillion won in 2020 to the 30 trillion won range last year. On top of this, additional incentives such as policy promotion expenses have further increased the cost burden.
Industry experts analyze that, in recent years, the rate of commission increases has outpaced the growth in new contract performance, leading to a higher overall commission rate. This means that the share of distribution channels in the value-added allocation structure of insurance premiums has grown.
This shift, in which 'distribution' puts pressure on 'manufacturing', is resulting in a decline in CSM margin rates industry-wide. Lee Byunggeon, Head of Research at DB Financial Investment, said, "Except for Hyundai Marine & Fire, all of the nine major non-life insurance companies have seen a decline in their CSM indicators relative to the present value of future insurance premiums," adding, "This recent decline in insurer CSM margins is attributable to the expansion of distribution margins, which has reduced manufacturing margins." He continued, "Intensifying competition, which the market had feared, is now weighing on margins. Although insurers are trying to control costs, the growing relative power of distribution channels is making business expense management increasingly difficult."
Solvency Warning Lights...Pressure to Shift Business Strategies
The problem is that this structure could lead not only to weakened profitability but also to capital and solvency issues. If insurers’ available profits decrease, they may not be able to adequately absorb risks arising from contracts. Additionally, some insurers are facing restrictions on dividends, not because they lack net profits, but due to the need to manage their risk-based capital ratios (K-ICS) and the burden of reserve requirements for surrender values.
Kang Seunggeon, Research Analyst at KB Securities, stated, "Under the current structure of surrender value reserves, the contract expenses incurred when selling new contracts account for a significant portion of the increase in surrender value reserves." He added, "Moreover, the CSM acquired at high cost is repeatedly being depleted due to declining persistency rates and changes in actuarial assumptions, indicating that a strategic shift is needed at this point."
Financial authorities are revising related systems out of concern that excessive commission competition could undermine insurers’ financial soundness in the long term. Starting in July, the "1200% rule"—which prevents initial-year recruitment commissions from exceeding the scheduled first-year premiums—will be extended to GA planners. All payments to insurance planners, including settlement support funds and policy promotion expenses beyond commissions, will be included in the commission cap calculation.
Beginning in 2027, a deferred commission system will be introduced, under which commissions to insurance planners will be paid in installments over four years. From 2029, a seven-year installment period will be implemented, and to prevent a steep drop in planners’ incomes, additional maintenance commissions will be temporarily paid during the four-year installment period. All of these institutional changes aim to ease excessive competition, reduce business expense burdens, strengthen consumer protection, and improve sales quality.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An insurance industry official commented, "Now, competitiveness depends not on how much you sell, but on how much profit you retain," adding, "Since commission regulations alone are limited, supplementary measures to enhance business expense efficiency are necessary." The official continued, "If business expenses continue to increase due to excessive competition, the burden may eventually be transferred to consumers. To ensure sustainability, institutional improvements must be accompanied by voluntary cost management efforts across the industry."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.