Lawsuit to Revoke Disclosure of Personal Information

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

A court has ruled that in order to disclose the personal information of individuals who refuse to fulfill their military service obligations and do not respond to summons for alternative service, the Military Manpower Administration must strictly adhere to the legally mandated procedures for prior notification and service of documents.


According to the legal community on April 12, the 12th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court (Presiding Judge Kang Jae-won) ruled in favor of the plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by Mr. A against the Commissioner of the Military Manpower Administration seeking to revoke the decision to make his personal information public.


Mr. A, who was subject to conscription, was assigned to alternative service in February 2021 following a decision by the Alternative Service Committee. Subsequently, the Gyeongin Regional Military Manpower Administration notified Mr. A twice, in 2022 and 2023, to report to the Alternative Service Training Center. However, Mr. A sent a statement expressing his position that “the current alternative service is punitive and unacceptable,” and did not respond to the summons.


On December 19, 2024, the Military Manpower Administration proceeded to disclose Mr. A's personal information, including his name, age, and address, on its website, citing his refusal to respond to the summons without justifiable reason. According to Article 81-2 of the Military Service Act, the Commissioner of the Military Manpower Administration may disclose the personal information and reasons for evasion of individuals who do not comply with conscription or alternative service summons without justifiable reason on the official website.


Mr. A filed a lawsuit on the merits, arguing that he lost the opportunity to explain himself because he did not receive prior notice, and that the Military Manpower Administration’s action was procedurally unlawful because it proceeded with the disclosure before the service by public notice took effect.


The Military Manpower Administration explained that after mail sent to Mr. A’s registered address was returned twice, it proceeded with the public notice procedure.


The court pointed out that, although Mr. A’s mobile phone number and email address were available in his military records, the Military Manpower Administration did not attempt to verify another address through these means before proceeding directly to the public notice procedure. Since the disclosure of personal information constitutes an adverse administrative action that restricts personality rights such as honor, the court held that it is inappropriate to move directly to public notice simply because mail was returned a few times.



The court also found it unlawful that the Military Manpower Administration disclosed Mr. A’s personal information before the public notice procedure had taken effect, and thus ruled in favor of Mr. A.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing