Coupang CLS, SK Energy: Applications Rejected, KEPCO: Separation Approved... Mixed Outcomes for Subcontractor Bargaining Unit Separation
On April 9, the Labor Relations Commission dismissed applications to separate the bargaining units for principals and subcontractors at Coupang Logistics Service (CLS), SK Energy, S-Oil, and Korea Zinc. However, in the case involving Korea Electric Power Corporation, the commission recognized the separation of the bargaining unit specifically for the "power distribution business."
On this day, the Seoul Regional Labor Relations Commission rejected an application filed by the National Courier Union, which requested that the union affiliated with the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions be separated into an independent bargaining unit among all subcontracted workers at Coupang Logistics Service. The adjudication committee determined that there was no significant difference in working conditions or employment types between the members of the union in question and other unions. In addition, the committee considered the purpose of the single bargaining channel system and the need to establish a stable and efficient bargaining structure.
Coupang posted sales of approximately 49 trillion won and net income of about 300 billion won last year. Last year's sales and net income represent the largest scale in history. Photo by Yonhap News, showing a Coupang center in Seoul on the 27th.
View original imageHowever, on March 10, the first day of the amended Trade Union Act coming into force, Coupang Logistics Service, which was the first in the parcel delivery industry to officially announce a bargaining demand, stated during the hearing that it recognized the status of the principal as an employer and expressed its intent to respond to collective bargaining requests from the subcontractor unions.
On the same day, the Ulsan Regional Labor Relations Commission also dismissed all applications filed by the National Plant Construction Workers' Union to separate the bargaining units for the three principal companies—SK Energy, S-Oil, and Korea Zinc. In this case as well, the application sought to establish an independent bargaining unit by separating a specific union from the overall bargaining unit of subcontracted workers.
The adjudication committee, after investigation and hearings, broadly recognized the status of the principals as employers. The grounds cited included the fact that maintenance work is essential for the operation of the principal's business, that safety guidelines and penalties for violations also apply to subcontracted workers, and that the authority to initiate or suspend work and to improve safety facilities is concentrated with the principal. In particular, regarding negotiation topics related to industrial safety and health, the committee judged that the principal holds a substantial and concrete position of control and decision-making.
Nevertheless, the commission ultimately did not accept the separation of the bargaining units. This decision was based on a comprehensive consideration of the following factors: there are not significant differences in working conditions or employment types among the unions; the interests regarding industrial safety issues are similar; and there is a concern that separating the units could widen disparities in working conditions between unions. The Ulsan Regional Labor Relations Commission will notify the parties of the decision and send a written statement of the specific grounds for the ruling within 30 days.
KEPCO: Separation Recognized... Differences in Working Conditions and Work Environment Acknowledged
In contrast, the Jeonnam Regional Labor Relations Commission reached a different conclusion by approving the separation of bargaining units in a case involving Korea Electric Power Corporation. The commission accepted the application by the National Construction Workers' Union to separate the "power distribution business" from the overall bargaining unit of Korea Electric Power Corporation’s subcontractors.
The Jeonnam Regional Labor Relations Commission recognized the principal's status as an employer, determining that Korea Electric Power Corporation, as the owner and manager of electric power facilities such as utility poles, transformers, and switching devices, directly controls the workspace of subcontracted workers and substantially governs and determines the work environment. In particular, regarding the separation of bargaining units, the commission cited as a key reason the significant differences in working conditions and work environments between the power distribution business and other areas such as transmission and transformation, meter reading, customer support, and facilities/environment maintenance.
Accordingly, the commission concluded that it is necessary to separate the business areas that perform inspection, maintenance, construction, and emergency repairs of power distribution facilities into an independent bargaining unit. The Jeonnam Regional Labor Relations Commission will also deliver a detailed written decision to the parties within 30 days.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
This series of rulings on this day continued the trend, following the enactment of the revised Trade Union Act, of broadly recognizing the principal’s status as an employer in principal-subcontractor relationships. However, regarding the separation of bargaining units, it appears that rather than applying a uniform standard, individual judgments are made based on a comprehensive consideration of factors such as industry characteristics, differences in working conditions, bargaining practices, union interests, and the stability of the bargaining structure.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.