A Flawed Authentication System That Cannot Even Distinguish Gender
Urgent Need for Measures to Prevent Youth Access to Harmful Environments
City: "We Will Strengthen Supervision to Protect Minors"

On the 8th, reporter Nam from this publication presented a woman's ID at a 24-hour unmanned electronic cigarette store in Dong-gu, Gwangju, and the purchase was completed without any restrictions. Photo by Min Hyunki

On the 8th, reporter Nam from this publication presented a woman's ID at a 24-hour unmanned electronic cigarette store in Dong-gu, Gwangju, and the purchase was completed without any restrictions. Photo by Min Hyunki

View original image

Recently, 24-hour unmanned electronic cigarette stores that promote cost savings on labor and convenience have seen a rapid increase. However, their core safety feature, the "adult authentication system," has been found to be ineffective. In particular, the authentication system is so poorly designed that it cannot even distinguish gender, making it a reality—rather than a mere concern—that minors can use someone else’s identification to purchase cigarettes. As a result, urgent measures are needed.


Completely Vulnerable to 'Female ID' Presented by Reporter Nam... "Unable to Verify Identity"

On April 8, our reporter Nam visited a 24-hour unmanned electronic cigarette store located in Dong-gu, Gwangju. The interior of the store was silent, with no manager present, and only vending machines displaying dozens of types of liquid electronic cigarettes and devices greeted the press. The phrase "No sales to anyone under 19" was clearly posted on the wall, but in reality, the machine’s security was just an empty formality.


After selecting a product, reporter Nam presented the ID card of a female acquaintance, rather than his own, to the authentication reader. Surprisingly, the vending machine approved the authentication in just a few seconds, failing to recognize any difference between the gender of the person in the ID photo and the buyer standing in front of the machine. Upon pressing the payment button, the product was dispensed without any issue.


According to current law, cigarette vending machines are required to have an adult authentication device. However, the system in use on-site only checks the validity of the ID and has no function to determine whether the user is actually the owner of the ID. In effect, as long as minors possess a parent’s, sibling’s, or even a lost stranger’s ID, they can easily obtain cigarettes.


Youth Say, "If You Secretly Take Your Parents’ ID, That’s Enough"... Increasing Cases of Identity Theft

Photo by Min Hyunki on the 8th at a 24-hour unmanned electronic cigarette store in Dong-gu, Gwangju.

Photo by Min Hyunki on the 8th at a 24-hour unmanned electronic cigarette store in Dong-gu, Gwangju.

View original image

With the full implementation of the revised Tobacco Business Act, which passed the National Assembly last year, synthetic nicotine liquid electronic cigarettes—previously in a regulatory blind spot—are now subject to the same regulation as regular cigarettes. Cigarette vending machines may only be installed in designated places, such as locations off-limits to those under 19 or inside retail stores, and strict adult authentication is mandatory.


However, experts point out that even with stronger legal frameworks, the lack of technical improvements renders these measures meaningless. The current simple scanning method cannot prevent the use of forged or stolen IDs. Experts unanimously argue that it should be mandatory to implement AI-based authentication systems with facial recognition or to use mobile ID QR codes that cannot be duplicated.


The flaws in these authentication systems are already an "open secret" among teenagers. They exploit the fact that, due to the nature of unmanned stores, in-person checks are impossible.


In fact, a high school student identified as "A," whom we met near Dong-gu, Gwangju, confessed, "I can’t go to convenience stores because I’m worried about being watched by the clerks, but it’s well known that if you just have an ID, unmanned stores are easy. If you secretly take your parents’ ID from home or use one bought on a secondhand trading site, you can make a purchase at the reader without any problem."



An official from Gwangju City stated, "We will reinforce anti-identity theft warnings through on-site inspections and actively encourage store owners to adopt more secure authentication systems." The official added, "We will establish an effective management system to ensure that minors are not exposed to harmful environments."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing