Punitive Taxation... Tax Shifting and Locked-In Supply
Beyond Metropolitan Supply: The Need for a Macro Strategy
Balanced National Development as the Solution to Real Estate Issues

Sungkyu Park, Professor at Willamette University, USA

Sungkyu Park, Professor at Willamette University, USA

View original image

Real estate is not simply an investment product; it is an essential good directly linked to the fundamental right to housing that every person deserves. Just as investment failures in the stock or cryptocurrency markets—often resulting from excessive leverage—frequently lead to individual bankruptcies, surging real estate prices and speculative behaviors in the housing market can drive ordinary citizens into overwhelming debt or high rent burdens, threatening their very survival. Therefore, the current administration's philosophical premise that the state must actively intervene in the market and define real estate speculation not merely as a means of capital accumulation but as a form of rent-seeking is well-founded.


According to a recent study, the explosive rise in housing prices has been empirically shown to affect both the younger generation and the macroeconomy. The research found that when young people perceive purchasing a home as increasingly unattainable due to soaring prices, they tend to stop long-term saving and increase current consumption, while also exhibiting reduced motivation to work. Furthermore, as accumulating assets through ordinary savings becomes impossible, there is a clear tendency for these individuals to turn to high-risk investments such as cryptocurrencies.


This suggests that rising housing prices are not just a matter of higher living costs, but a key factor in entrenching intergenerational wealth inequality and reducing the overall labor productivity of the nation. Stabilizing the market through targeted support to ensure that young people without homes do not lose hope of homeownership is an essential task for the future of the national economy.


Against this backdrop, the current administration's real estate policy is being developed with two main pillars: curbing speculative demand and expanding housing supply. In particular, the financial regulation that fundamentally prohibits multi-homeowners from extending the maturity of home-backed loans is highly positive. This measure preemptively blocks the practice of gap investing, in which a small number of individuals monopolize limited housing resources and profit from others’ housing costs, and controls the explosive growth of household debt. It thus aligns with the goal of macroeconomic stabilization.


However, punitive market control policies using taxation are clearly accompanied by economic side effects. First, there is the phenomenon of tax shifting. While the government increases property holding taxes—such as property tax and comprehensive real estate tax—to pressure multi-homeowners, this burden is easily passed on to tenants in the form of higher deposit requirements or increased monthly rent. As a result, policies intended to protect actual residents risk raising real housing costs for ordinary citizens without homes.


Second, high capital gains taxes lead to a phenomenon known as "locked-in supply." In order to encourage existing multi-homeowners to release properties onto the market, an exit strategy must be provided. However, the current high capital gains tax environment leads such owners to transfer their properties to their children or hold onto them for prolonged periods, rather than selling. This sharply reduces the volume of homes circulating in the market, which in turn stimulates further price increases.


The most certain way to stabilize prices in the market is to secure sufficient supply. The current administration is also aware of this and is pursuing rapid expansion of housing supply as a major policy by utilizing publicly owned land within urban areas.


However, the fact that current supply plans are focused only on urban centers in the metropolitan area reveals a structural limitation. The fundamental reason people flock to the Seoul metropolitan area despite high housing costs is the concentration of quality jobs, education, and core infrastructure. Merely increasing supply in metropolitan city centers cannot accommodate the endless influx of demand.


True stabilization of the real estate market must go beyond policies centered on the metropolitan area and be achieved in conjunction with balanced national development. To fundamentally disperse demand concentrated in the Seoul metropolitan area, institutional incentives must be provided to encourage businesses and universities to relocate to other regions, and quality housing and living infrastructure must be established in those areas.


The current administration must minimize the side effects of holding tax increases being passed on to tenants and carefully coordinate transaction tax relief to ensure that multi-homeowners’ properties can be smoothly supplied to the market. Furthermore, it is time to move beyond short-term supply measures in the metropolitan area and to vigorously pursue a macro-level spatial strategy that fosters the self-sufficiency of regional economies, enabling young people to enjoy comfortable housing at reasonable prices in any part of the country.



Sungkyu Park, Professor at Willamette University, USA


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing