Lawsuit Against Reconstruction Association Over Return of Commercial Lease Deposit

Supreme Court Overturns Lower Ruling in Part, Favors Tenant

Supreme Court: "Lease Relationship Continues Until Deposit Is Returned"

Even if the term of a commercial lease contract has expired, if the tenant has not yet received the security deposit back and the ownership of the commercial property changes hands, the new owner must assume the landlord’s position and return the deposit, according to a Supreme Court ruling.


Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

According to the legal community on April 9, the Supreme Court’s 3rd Division (Presiding Justice Lee Heung-Koo) overturned the lower court’s decision, which had ruled against tenant A in a lawsuit for the return of the commercial lease deposit and other claims filed against B Housing Reconstruction and Maintenance Association, which acquired the building. The Supreme Court returned the case to the lower court regarding the claim for the return of the lease deposit.


Tenant A had rented a commercial property within a redevelopment zone and operated a business there. The lease contract expired at the end of December 2021. Subsequently, Association B completed the registration of transfer of ownership for the building in January 2022, and the transfer of the building was executed in April of the same year.


As a result, A filed a lawsuit, arguing that Association B, as the new owner, had succeeded to the landlord’s status and should return the deposit, as well as compensate for obstruction of premium recovery and business losses incurred after the execution of the building transfer.


The courts of first and second instance ruled in favor of Association B and dismissed all of A’s claims. They held that since Association B acquired ownership after the commercial lease contract had already expired, it did not succeed to the status of the previous landlord.


However, the Supreme Court reached a different conclusion. The Supreme Court panel focused on Article 9, Paragraph 2 of the Commercial Building Lease Protection Act, which stipulates that even if the lease has ended, the lease relationship is deemed to continue until the tenant receives the deposit back.


The panel stated, “In the case of a commercial lease with enforceability, even when the lease has ended due to expiration or other reasons, the lease relationship is deemed to continue until the deposit is returned. If the commercial property is transferred while in this state, the transferee naturally assumes the position of landlord at the point when the lease has ended.”


This means that if the tenant’s lease has enforceability, the new owner who purchases the building assumes the obligation to return the deposit regardless of whether the contract has expired.



However, the panel dismissed Association B’s appeal regarding damages, stating, “It is ultimately acceptable that the lower court found Association B did not obstruct the recovery of the premium or bear liability for business losses.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing