"Unstable U.S.-Iran Ceasefire... Ongoing Risk of Low-Intensity Renewed Conflict" - CSIS
The United States and Iran have entered a two-week ceasefire, but analysis suggests this truce is highly unstable, and that the risk of renewed conflict remains significant as the ceasefire becomes entrenched. Due to major differences in their positions on multiple issues—including the Iranian nuclear program, Tehran’s support for proxy forces, and transit fees in the Strait of Hormuz—reaching a comprehensive peace agreement is not expected to be easy.
Daniel Byman, Director of the War, Irregular Threats, and Terrorism Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) and professor at Georgetown University, wrote on the CSIS website on April 8 (local time) in an article titled “The Fragile U.S.-Iran Ceasefire: Issues to Watch” that the ceasefire is highly precarious and fraught with challenges.
The following is a full translation of the article.
After more than a month of fighting, the United States and Iran have agreed to a two-week ceasefire. However, this ceasefire remains highly unstable, and many of the key factors that will determine its sustainability are still uncertain. Below are six issues to watch as negotiations proceed.
Ceasefire or Final Agreement?
For now, what the United States, Israel, and Iran have agreed upon is no more than a ceasefire—nothing beyond that. Numerous issues, including Iran’s nuclear and missile programs, Tehran’s support for proxy forces, and the domestic crackdown on protesters, remain unresolved. Conversely, Iran is demanding that the United States lift sanctions against it, guarantee its right to enrich uranium, halt Israel’s attacks on Lebanon, and provide assurances against any future resumption of attacks on Iran. The war itself has introduced new demands. Iran is seeking compensation for damages caused by U.S. and Israeli airstrikes and is insisting on imposing transit fees on oil tankers passing through the Strait of Hormuz. The gap between the two sides’ positions is wide, and both countries are under pressure to present themselves as victorious to their domestic audiences, further complicating negotiations.
Ultimately, there is a possibility that the ceasefire itself will become a de facto endpoint. The United States, Israel, and Iran may fail to reach a final agreement, resulting in an indefinite continuation of the ceasefire while the risk of renewed conflict remains ever-present.
The Iranian Nuclear Program
The Iranian nuclear program has been at the core of U.S.-Iran tensions for decades. The United States has used a variety of means—sanctions, cyberattacks, negotiations, and limited military force—to try to contain it. The United States and Israel destroyed a significant portion of Iran’s nuclear program during the December 2025 war and conducted additional strikes in the 2026 conflict. Currently, many Iranian facilities and stockpiles are buried under tons of rubble.
Throughout this period, Iran has continued to insist that it does not seek nuclear weapons, while adamantly defending its right to enrich uranium. However, the United States and Israel have long viewed this as a covert pathway to nuclear weapons development.
The nuclear issue remains unresolved. Iran is even claiming that, as part of the ceasefire agreement, the United States has recognized its right to enrich uranium, though this is likely not true. While U.S. and Israeli military operations have increased the distance between Iran and possessing nuclear weapons, they may also have strengthened Tehran’s conviction that nuclear arms are the only means to defend itself against the conventional military superiority of the United States and Israel, thus increasing its determination to pursue nuclear capabilities.
The Lebanon Front
This ceasefire covers attacks on Iran, but Israel claims that it does not apply to its operations against Hezbollah in Lebanon. In reality, Israel has continued its strikes in Lebanon. The Lebanon war has been as destructive as the Iran war. Nearly 1,500 Lebanese have been killed, over one million have fled their homes, and Israel is creating a buffer zone on the Lebanese side of the Israel-Lebanon border.
If Iran is weakened, Hezbollah is also likely to be weakened, though the process is extremely complex and dangerous. Ongoing Israeli military pressure could diminish Hezbollah’s capabilities and loosen its ties to Iran. However, Lebanon’s institutional foundations may collapse more quickly than they can recover, leaving a power vacuum rather than a stronger state. As a result, while Hezbollah may be weakened, it will not disappear entirely, the state will be further hollowed out, and Lebanon will become even more vulnerable to long-term internal and external shocks.
Terrorism and Retaliation
The U.S. and Israeli attacks on Iran have, in the short term, heightened the risk of international terrorism by Iran and its proxies, especially Hezbollah in Lebanon. Iran has already attempted to broaden the front by targeting U.S. allies in the Gulf, and terrorism may become another tool to impose costs on Washington and its allies. If hostilities resume, the Iranian leadership may conclude that it needs to inflict even greater pain to deter further attacks. Even during the ceasefire, there are strong incentives for retaliation. Tehran has previously plotted attacks in retaliation for the assassination of senior officials, and the loss of more than 250 high-ranking figures in this conflict is unprecedented. At the same time, the current conflict has provided a backdrop for anti-Israel and anti-Jewish violence, even if it is not directly orchestrated by the Iranian government.
However, Iran’s attempts at terrorism may fail or even backfire. The United States and Israel have invested massive resources over many years to disrupt Iranian networks, and considering the level of intelligence penetration revealed during the recent war, there is a high likelihood that plots for overseas attacks could be thwarted in advance. Should an attack succeed on U.S. soil, domestic support for military action against Iran, which has so far been limited, could actually increase. Similarly, attacks on allied countries could strengthen public opinion and political unity against Iran, reinforcing the U.S.- and Israel-led coalition.
On the other hand, the threat of terrorism itself could diminish. Iran and its key proxies like Hamas and Hezbollah have already suffered significant military and organizational losses. In this situation, they may opt to refrain from large-scale attacks that could provoke further retaliation and erode their already weakened capabilities.
How Will Allies and Partners View the United States?
In the long run, the most significant damage to the United States from the Iran war may be its relationship with allies around the world. This conflict has been extremely unpopular in Europe, and it has exacerbated inflation and slowed growth in Asia and other regions. To make matters worse, the United States did not sufficiently consult with NATO allies before the war and criticized them for not taking on difficult missions such as reopening the Strait of Hormuz when the situation deteriorated. More realistically, the United States has depleted scarce air defense capabilities and various military assets in the Iran war, reducing its ability to deter Russia and support allies in countering China. China sees this war as an opportunity to weaken U.S. influence and portray the United States as an impulsive and belligerent power.
It is possible that the international community will quickly move on from this issue, and that China’s aggressive stance over Taiwan and the South China Sea may actually prevent negative perceptions of the United States from spreading further. Nevertheless, the United States is likely to face a future in which its allies approach their relationships with more caution and calculation.
The War After the War
Even after the end of large-scale hostilities, Israel and Iran are more likely to remain in a state of ongoing, lower-intensity conflict than to transition to a stable peace. Militarily, Israel has not achieved a decisive victory, and may judge that it needs to continue striking to prevent Iran from rebuilding its missile stockpiles and to keep pressure on Iranian leadership. Conversely, Tehran may come to believe that, regardless of its restraint, it will ultimately be attacked, further reinforcing the logic of ongoing resistance and retaliation.
Domestic political considerations and strategic pressures on both sides also reinforce this dynamic. For Iran’s leadership, continued confrontation justifies domestic repression and diverts attention from economic hardship and political dissatisfaction. Israel, for its part, has long favored a strategy of “operations between wars,” seeking to keep Iran and its proxies weak and off-balance by striking before they can recover. The likely result is a pattern of cyberattacks, proxy wars, limited strikes, and periodic escalations, making the postwar order less a tidy peace and more a “war after the war.” Even if the United States seeks to step back, its close alignment with Israel means it will remain exposed to the risk of Iranian retaliation, making it difficult to break out of this vicious cycle.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
In the end, this ceasefire is more a pause than a resolution of the conflict. The fundamental causes of the dispute remain unresolved, and in some respects have even deepened. The nuclear issue remains unsolved, Lebanon is destabilized, the threat of terrorism persists, and America’s alliances have been shaken. Meanwhile, Israel and Iran both have strong incentives to continue their shadow war, which could periodically erupt into open conflict. Even if large-scale fighting does not resume immediately, the United States will continue to face a Middle East dominated by persistent instability, emboldened adversaries, wary allies, and cycles of escalation that are difficult to control or conclude.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.