Labor Commission Recognizes 'Principal Employer Status'
First Ruling Since the Implementation of the Yellow Envelope Act

As the National Labor Relations Commission ruled that POSCO must negotiate separately with subcontractor labor unions, the impact is spreading across large corporations with similar subcontracting structures. With this being the first case in which the principal contractor's employer status has been recognized, concerns are rising within industries such as shipbuilding, steel, and construction—where multi-layered subcontracting structures are common—that the burden of 'year-round negotiations' could become a reality.


According to business circles on April 9, the decision by the North Gyeongsang Provincial Labor Relations Commission is being interpreted as a signal that labor-management relations across the industry could undergo structural changes beyond just one company. The previous day, the Commission announced that it had accepted the application from the Korea Metal Workers' Union, which is affiliated with the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU), to separate its bargaining unit from the Korea Metal Workers’ Federation of the Federation of Korean Trade Unions (FKTU), as well as the application from the KCTU-affiliated Plant Construction Workers’ Union demanding separate negotiations from the Metal Workers’ Union.

"POSCO Must Negotiate Separately with Three Subcontractor Unions"... 'Year-Round Negotiations' Become Reality View original image

With this decision, POSCO must now negotiate not only with the primary union but also separately with at least three subcontractor unions. These include the KCTU Metal Workers’ Union, the FKTU Metal Workers’ Federation, and the KCTU Plant Construction Workers’ Union.


If bargaining units are not integrated and are instead split into individual unions, negotiations could continue throughout the year as each union raises demands at different times. In particular, since employees doing the same work at the same site can negotiate independently simply because they belong to different higher-level unions, there are growing concerns that the once-feared scenario of 'year-round negotiations' has now materialized for companies.


Byung-Hoon Lee, Professor Emeritus of Sociology at Chung-Ang University, commented, "Since this is the first case where separate bargaining requests from subcontractor unions have been accepted, conflicts may arise among unions regarding the order and scope of negotiations. If the first union to negotiate sets the standard for wage or working condition improvements, subsequent unions are likely to follow this so-called 'pattern bargaining' model." A representative from the POSCO union stated, "We respect the decision of the Labor Commission and will monitor developments moving forward."



In practice, a flood of applications for separation of bargaining units is being filed at worksites. According to labor community data, as of April 7, a total of 987 unions, representing 144,000 members, have demanded negotiations with the principal contractor. There are 368 principal contractors that have received such negotiation requests.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing