Controversy Over Equal Value of Votes Unavoidable After Integration
Possible Violation of Constitutional Court Standards

At a Crossroads: Increasing Seats vs. Electoral System Reform
Five Parliamentary Parties Reach Agreement on Metropo

The unified special city is being established, but how the metropolitan council—which is meant to serve as a check on this new city—will be formed has yet to be decided. It remains unresolved whether the significant gap in the number of metropolitan council members between Gwangju (23) and Jeonnam (61) will be maintained, whether the total number of seats will be increased, or whether a multi-member constituency system will be introduced. Meanwhile, the deadline for amending the election law is approaching.

Promotional image announcing the promotion of Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City. Provided by Jeonnam Province

Promotional image announcing the promotion of Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City. Provided by Jeonnam Province

View original image

The starting point of the debate is the numbers. As of January this year, the population of Gwangju is 1.39 million, while Jeonnam’s is 1.78 million. However, the number of metropolitan council members stands at 23 for Gwangju and 61 for Jeonnam. If the integration proceeds under these circumstances, Gwangju citizens will have one metropolitan council member per approximately 60,000 people, while Jeonnam residents will have one per about 29,000 people. This means the weight of a vote could differ by nearly twofold within the same special city. This is why concerns are being raised that controversy over representation will be unavoidable immediately after integration.


In relation to this, Cho Kuk, leader of the Party for Justice and Innovation, stated, "If elections are held based on the current constituency boundaries, the 12 constituencies in Gwangju will exceed the population upper limit, while 11 constituencies in Jeonnam will fall below the lower limit," adding, "A total of 23 constituencies may not meet the standards set by the Constitutional Court." He pointed out that if Gwangju and Jeonnam are integrated under these circumstances, there could be immediate controversy over unconstitutionality.

'23 vs. 61'... How will the imbalance in representation be addressed?


One solution proposed to address the imbalance in representation is to increase the number of metropolitan council members for Gwangju, and this approach has already been introduced as a bill in the National Assembly. Assemblyman Kim Moonsu of the Democratic Party of Korea has sponsored an amendment to the Public Official Election Act that would increase the number of Gwangju city council members while maintaining the current number of Jeonnam provincial council members. If this proposal is implemented, the number of Gwangju metropolitan council members would rise from the current 23 to 46.

Photo by Hyunmin Kim kimhyun81@

Photo by Hyunmin Kim kimhyun81@

View original image

The National Election Commission has also reportedly submitted an opinion during the Special Committee on Political Reform discussions, highlighting the need to increase Gwangju’s seats.


However, there is also opposition within the political community. The People Power Party has raised concerns that, after integration, the number of metropolitan council members could become excessively large compared to other regions. For instance, Daegu, with a population of about 2.35 million, has 33 city council members, and Gyeongbuk, with roughly 2.5 million people, has about 60 provincial council members. Assemblyman Kim Seungsoo of the People Power Party stated during the National Assembly’s Special Committee on Political Reform, "When adjusted for population, Gwangju and Jeonnam already have a relatively high number of metropolitan council members, so increasing the number further after integration would only worsen the imbalance," expressing his opposition.


Increase in the number of seats or introduction of multi-member constituencies... At a crossroads for electoral system reform


There is also discussion about fundamentally changing the electoral system itself. To mitigate the population representation imbalance arising from the integration of metropolitan entities, a bill to introduce a multi-member constituency system—electing 3 to 5 metropolitan council members per district using the current National Assembly constituencies—has been proposed in the National Assembly. The bill was jointly sponsored by Assemblywoman Lim Mi-ae of the Democratic Party of Korea, Assemblyman Jeong Chun-sang of the Party for Justice and Innovation, and Assemblywoman Jeong Hye-kyung of the Progressive Party.


This bill includes explicit language on "equal value of votes, proportionality, and diversity of composition" and aims to strengthen the council’s function of checking the expanded authority of the unified special city’s mayor. The National Assembly Research Service also noted in its report, "Key Contents and Future Tasks of the Special Act on Metropolitan Administrative Integration," that, "Compared to the emergence of a local government head with powerful authority, the functions to monitor and check this power are relatively weak," and stressed the need to strengthen the role of local councils and revitalize systems for resident participation to effectively oversee the unified special city’s executive branch.

Partial revision of the Public Official Election Act proposed by Mi-Ae Lim, a member of the Democratic Party of Korea, and others. It includes provisions specifying "equality of vote value, proportionality, and diversity of composition" in the formation of integrated special city councils, and stipulates that 3 to 5 metropolitan council members be elected based on the constituency boundaries of National Assembly elections.

Partial revision of the Public Official Election Act proposed by Mi-Ae Lim, a member of the Democratic Party of Korea, and others. It includes provisions specifying "equality of vote value, proportionality, and diversity of composition" in the formation of integrated special city councils, and stipulates that 3 to 5 metropolitan council members be elected based on the constituency boundaries of National Assembly elections.

View original image

In the 2022 local elections, the Gwangju City Council saw the Democratic Party of Korea secure 22 out of 23 seats, with the People Power Party winning just one proportional seat. Similarly, in the Jeonnam Provincial Council, the Democratic Party won 56 out of 61 seats, with the Progressive Party winning 2, and the People Power Party, Justice Party, and independents each winning 1 seat. With this structure, where a single party dominates both the executive and the local council, how to design the council’s oversight function after the launch of the unified special city remains a key challenge.


Against this backdrop, on April 2, the five major parliamentary parties—the Democratic Party of Korea, the Party for Justice and Innovation, the Progressive Party, the Basic Income Party, and the Social Democratic Party—held a press conference in front of the main National Assembly building. They announced a joint declaration to expand the multi-member constituency system for basic councils beyond the previous local elections, to promote the introduction of the multi-member constituency system for metropolitan council elections, and to increase the proportion of proportional representation seats for metropolitan councils from the current 10%.


They stated their intention to push for the passage of the relevant amendment to the Public Official Election Act at the National Assembly plenary session before April 10. However, since electoral system reform has traditionally been handled through bipartisan agreement in the Special Committee on Political Reform, whether the People Power Party will cooperate remains a key variable for the reform’s success.


Deadline for election law amendment approaches... Political decision remains


The issue now is time. The National Election Commission’s position is that amendments to election-related laws must be finalized by April 17, followed by promulgation and implementation on the 22nd, submission of the basic council constituency revision plan to city and provincial councils on the 24th, and the enforcement of the revised constituency ordinance on the 1st of the following month. This schedule is effectively regarded as the final deadline.

The floor leaders of the five democratic reform-progressive parties signed a joint declaration for the completion of political reform and the restoration of constitutional order at the political reform tent protest in front of the National Assembly Main Building on the 2nd. Han Byungdo, floor leader of the Democratic Party of Korea (third from the left), is speaking. From the left, Changmin Han, leader of the Social Democratic Party; Wangjin Seo, floor leader of the Party for National Innovation; Byungdo Han, floor leader; Jongoh Yoon, floor leader of the Progressive Party; and Jihye Shin, supreme council member of the Basic Income Party. Photo by Yonhap News.

The floor leaders of the five democratic reform-progressive parties signed a joint declaration for the completion of political reform and the restoration of constitutional order at the political reform tent protest in front of the National Assembly Main Building on the 2nd. Han Byungdo, floor leader of the Democratic Party of Korea (third from the left), is speaking. From the left, Changmin Han, leader of the Social Democratic Party; Wangjin Seo, floor leader of the Party for National Innovation; Byungdo Han, floor leader; Jongoh Yoon, floor leader of the Progressive Party; and Jihye Shin, supreme council member of the Basic Income Party. Photo by Yonhap News.

View original image

The Party for Justice and Innovation has once again emphasized the need to expand the multi-member constituency system. On April 8, Seo Wangjin, floor leader of the Party for Justice and Innovation and head of its Gwangju branch, stated in a press conference at the Gwangju City Council briefing room, "On April 2, the Democratic Party of Korea, the Party for Justice and Innovation, and three other parties agreed to expand multi-member constituencies for basic councils, introduce them for metropolitan councils, and increase the proportion of proportional representative seats. A balanced structure for metropolitan councils suited to local autonomy and administrative integration is necessary."


He went on to raise concerns that the Democratic Party of Korea is focusing solely on increasing the number of seats, warning of so-called "gerrymandering" (the act of manipulating electoral districts to favor a particular party). He called for the acceptance of political reform measures, including: expanding all basic council constituencies to at least three-member multi-member districts; introducing a multi-member constituency system for metropolitan councils with at least three members per district; and raising the proportion of proportional representation seats to at least 20%.



The Progressive Party has also highlighted the need to address the problem of imbalanced representation. Lee Jong-wook, the Progressive Party’s candidate for mayor of the Jeonnam-Gwangju special city, argued, "There is nearly a threefold difference in the number of metropolitan council members between Jeonnam (61) and Gwangju (23) in the unified city. The value of a Gwangju citizen’s vote does not even reach half that of a Jeonnam resident, which is a clear violation of the population deviation standard set by the Constitutional Court." He further stated, "The National Assembly’s Special Committee on Political Reform must respond to demands to address the imbalance in representation by introducing the multi-member constituency system and increasing the number of proportional representatives."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing