FTC: "360 Billion Won Virtually Lent Interest-Free to Affiliate for 17 Years"

HDC Issues Statement: "Will Prove 'Legitimate Act' Through Legal Procedures"

HDC has stated that the imposition of a 17.13 billion won fine and a corporate complaint by the Fair Trade Commission (FTC) for alleged unfair support to its affiliate HDC I'Park Mall was "a decision made to rescue more than 3,000 individual retail unit buyers facing a vacancy crisis," expressing "deep regret" over the matter.


On April 8, HDC issued a statement, saying, "We are very disappointed that our public-interest, rational management decision for mutual survival has been deemed unfair support," and added, "We will clarify through legal procedures that this was a legitimate transaction and a justified act."


The FTC announced on the same day that HDC, in 2006, leased a portion of Yongsan I'Park Mall retail space for 36 billion won and delegated operational rights in a 'package deal' structure, thereby indirectly providing ultra-low interest funds to its affiliate. The FTC determined that, as a result, the financially troubled affiliate was able to survive in the market and gain a competitive edge.


Aerial view of HDC I'Park Mall in Yongsan-gu, Seoul. HDC

Aerial view of HDC I'Park Mall in Yongsan-gu, Seoul. HDC

View original image

HDC strongly refuted this assessment by the FTC, arguing that it excluded the full context of the incident. At the time of the mall’s opening in 2006, a large-scale vacancy crisis forced over 3,000 investors to bear not only losses on their investment but also the burden of maintenance fees and taxes for the vacant retail units.


In its statement, HDC explained, "At that time, the Yongsan Private Station Complex was facing the risk of closure due to massive vacancies in its early days, and more than 3,000 retail unit buyers were on the verge of financial ruin due to investment losses. These buyers demanded exemption from maintenance fees and requested entrusted management of the retail units, and strongly insisted that HDC enter into lease and operational management agreements under the same conditions as them, to which we complied." HDC emphasized that this was a "measure for mutual survival to prevent a chain collapse among small business owners," not an act of unfair support to an affiliate.


The Yongsan Private Station Complex had achieved a 95% sales rate through a rental-sales model in 2001, but after operations began in 2004, limitations of the collective retail format and an underdeveloped commercial area resulted in an occupancy rate of only 68% as of September 2005. A representative from HDC stated, "This was a period when collective retail complexes like Dongdaemun Good Morning City were repeatedly collapsing. To prevent losses for the retail unit buyers, HDC signed lease agreements and took on entrusted management under the same conditions as the buyers." The representative added, "This move was made with the consent of nearly 100% of the retail unit buyers."


HDC also disputed the FTC’s argument that these actions disrupted fair competition in the mixed-use shopping mall market. Yongsan Private Station Complex operates under a business agreement with KORAIL, in accordance with the former National Railroad Management Special Act, allowing the recovery of project costs through rental income over 30 years. As the market structure does not permit free entry by other companies, HDC contends that it is not possible to argue that competitors were excluded. An HDC representative stated, "Only designated operators can run the business according to the agreement with KORAIL, and even if HDC were to withdraw from the project, there is no structure in which a third party could take its place."



Regarding why the justification of responding to initial vacancies was maintained for an extended period, an HDC representative said, "This is because the vacancy issue was not resolved in a short period." The representative added, "Despite our own efforts to normalize operations, I'Park Mall is still in financial distress, and last year we took steps to resolve the financial crisis by reducing capital."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing